Should Hatton be on the P4P list?

[flipside]

here's my list:
1.mayweather
2.Winky Wright
3.bernard hopkins
4.manny pacquiao
5.zab judah
6.marco antonio barera
7.jermain taylor
8.hatton
9.corrales
10castillo

i think im biased... but whatb the hey...

[Guest]

Here's a Q... should the concept of p4p be attributed just to division or be taken more literally?

Because Lewis gave Holyfield a pretty one-sided hammering in their first fight, but he's a lot bigger, isn't he? Could we say (back in the day, natch) that Holyfield is p4p a better fighter than Rid**** Bowe?

[TuPrincipe]

I think P4P should be based on your ability to move up through the weight classes and DOMINATE.

[SugaShane]

here's my list:
1.mayweather
2.Winky Wright
3.bernard hopkins
4.manny pacquiao
5.zab judah
6.marco antonio barera
7.jermain taylor
8.hatton
9.corrales10castillo

i think im biased... but whatb the hey...

other then the ones I bolded your list is OK..how do you have corrales before castillo when castillo basically won both fights (mouthpiece bull****). How do u have taylor 4 behind hopkins when the fight was very close it should be 3. Hopkins and 4. Taylor..who exactly has judah beaten to be top 5?