Pound-for-Pound: The Fifty Greatest Boxers Of All-Time

[TOBYLEE1]

Maybe you should just create a thread and make a case against Azumah because it's obvious you can't make one for Oscar. Wilfredo Gomez isn't Azumah's best win BTW but..again...I know you're slow...try and stick to the topic.

What is Oscar's career defining win? Go ahead.

Dazed, you are wasting your time with this guy. He is inmune to common sense and thinks that he knows it all. Its like talking to a wall

[Mr. Fantastic]

Resume being strong is one thing. All-time Great is another.

Floyd Mayweather is an ATG but yet he has a weaker resume than Oscar.

[americanbot]

Plenty.

I don't rate Duran in the Top 5, but he has an argument.

He's a consensus Top 10 ATG.

again.......show me what boxing expert rates reberto duran @ p4p 4th greatest fighter of all time...........

please show & tell............I'll be waiting for this.

[IMDAZED]

I'm just helping out that dude
But he should be just really low on the list ahead of people like chalzage yes ahead of the bhops and Durans and Leonard's hell no

He doesn't belong in the top 50 and I think everyone knows that. Mr. Fantastic is just a fanatic. Don't get it really. For the most part, Oscar was a mean SOB in the ring but I find it hard to be a fan of someone who probably spends his days lounging around the GBP offices waiting for a fresh-faced boxer to walk in so he can get his grope on.

[IMDAZED]

Floyd Mayweather is an ATG but yet he has a weaker resume than Oscar.

How so? according to you, Oscar beat Leija, Azumah lost therefore Oscar >>>>. Using your logic, Floyd beat Oscar so Floyd >>>>.

[KnockUTheFukOut]

no reason to get upset over someones PERSONAL ALL-TIME LIST

it is just SOMEONES OPINIONS

I would like to see some legendary fighters do a round table and come up with a list, get like maybe Larry Holmes, Roy Jones, George Foreman, Lennox Lewis Mike Tyson, Ray Leonard, Thomas Hearns, Hagler, guys like that and get their opinions because some ***in nerdy a$$ reporter who never took a punch to the face or put on a pair of Gloves coming up with a "ALL TIME GREATS LIST" is a JOKE to me and it is no way i can take any of them serious...Imagine Elie Sechbech trying to make a Top 50 list, do you know how LAUGHABLE that list would be lol his Top 3 would probably be: Manny Pacquiao, Yuri Foreman and Dmitry Salita lol

[Rassclot]

I know right! Who the hell are Harry Greb, Georges Carpentier, Tommy Loughran, Tommy Gibbons, Battling Levinsky and the rest? Nobodies!

Harry Greb the middleweight? Are you joking me right now?


Carpentier is the most overrated Frenchie to ever walk the earth.

The rest of them are nobodies. Sorry bud.

[Mr. Fantastic]

No, but you should at least realize that Chavez and Whitaker were well past their primes when Delahoya beat them. And a lot of people don't think Delahoya deserved the decision over Whitaker.

Whitaker was in the P4P list when DLH fought him. I think he was #1 or #2.

Since you want to talk about being past their prime....you might as well take 99% of the big wins from everyone in boxing. From Tyson to Lewis to Floyd, etc.

Whitaker lost that fight. He should of let his hands go more instead of being all flashy with his defense. It was close but Oscar won it. Defensive style fans would disagree but 1 punch compared to 5 just won't cut it for me.

[joseph5620]

He's had several.

From Hernandez to Whitaker to Chavez to Quartey to Vargas. What I find funny is that you guys praise boxers for the same thing but it's double standards with Oscar. Like Floyd beating Hernandez and Gatti....OMG! DLH beat them earlier and they aren't as good.

Speaking for myself, I give both Oscar and Floyd credit for beating Hernandez. But Gatti is not a great win for either one.

[Mr. Fantastic]

He doesn't belong in the top 50 and I think everyone knows that. Mr. Fantastic is just a fanatic. Don't get it really. For the most part, Oscar was a mean SOB in the ring but I find it hard to be a fan of someone who probably spends his days lounging around the GBP offices waiting for a fresh-faced boxer to walk in so he can get his grope on.

How am I a fanatic you dumb fuck? Do you see me claiming Oscar as a top 20 ATG or something? Not at all. I've stated in the past that Oscar deserves to be an ATG but not with legends. ****ing idiot!

How so? according to you, Oscar beat Leija, Azumah lost therefore Oscar >>>>. Using your logic, Floyd beat Oscar so Floyd >>>>.

Oscar didn't lose to the Leija's of the world was my logic. As well as Azumah couldn't even get passed guys that Oscar beat with ease apart from Whitaker.