Pound-for-Pound: The Fifty Greatest Boxers Of All-Time

[JAB5239]

Harry Greb the middleweight? Are you joking me right now?


Carpentier is the most overrated Frenchie to ever walk the earth.

The rest of them are nobodies. Sorry bud.

You mean the Harry Greb who Dempsey ducked? Your knowledge of boxing history is sorely lacking.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Speaking for myself, I give both Oscar and Floyd credit for beating Hernandez. But Gatti is not a great win for either one.

I remember you were specifically saying Lewis was better than any Klit. Some of Lewis' best wins were against Tyson and Holyfield. Guys who were already at the end of the road. You gotta have the same standards for everyone Joseph.

[americanbot]

BTW


i rate

ali

robinson

pep

armstrong

Louis

Foreman


all over duran. thats six already. if i wanted to i could throw 4 more which would make 10........i don't see how duran is a top 4 greatest fighter of all time.

in fact it's a complete joke................

[IMDAZED]

How am I a fanatic you dumb fuck? Do you see me claiming Oscar as a top 20 ATG or something? Not at all. I've stated in the past that Oscar deserves to be an ATG but not with legends. ****ing idiot!




Oscar didn't lose to the Leija's of the world was my logic. As well as Azumah couldn't even get passed guys that Oscar beat with ease apart from Whitaker.

If you feel Oscar deserves to be an ATG...make a case for him instead of sounding like a whiny ho. Who did he beat that quantifies and qualifies him? And try to keep them in context (as in, when) so we know you have a functioning brain.

[StarshipTrooper]

Harry Greb the middleweight? Are you joking me right now?


Carpentier is the most overrated Frenchie to ever walk the earth.

The rest of them are nobodies. Sorry bud.

You know, I wasn't planning on posting again but referring to Loughran and Gibbons as "nobodies" is just too ****ing ignorant to let pass. You obviously don't know **** about the sport you're attempting to comment on. The next time the subject of fighters from further back than ten years ago comes up you should keep your mouth shut instead of talking out of your ass.

Poet

[IMDAZED]

You know, I wasn't planning on posting again but referring to Loughran and Gibbons as "nobodies" is just too ****ing ignorant to let pass. You obviously don't know **** about the sport you're attempting to comment on. The next time the subject of fighters from further back than ten years ago comes up you should keep your mouth shut instead of talking out of your ass.

Poet

[jrosales13]

BTW


i rate

ali

robinson

pep

armstrong

Louis

Foreman


all over duran. thats six already. if i wanted to i could throw 4 more which would make 10........i don't see how duran is a top 4 greatest fighter of all time.

in fact it's a complete joke................

You can name 400 fighters over Duran doesn't mean anything....Foreman? I guess.

[StarshipTrooper]

BTW


i rate

ali

robinson

pep

armstrong

Louis

Foreman


all over duran. thats six already. if i wanted to i could throw 4 more which would make 10........i don't see how duran is a top 4 greatest fighter of all time.

in fact it's a complete joke................

Duran's the consensus GOAT at Lightweight. Of course he's going to get consideration for top-5 p4p.

Poet

[JAB5239]

BTW


i rate

ali

robinson

pep

armstron

Louis

Foreman


all over duran. thats six already. if i wanted to i could throw 4 more which would make 10........i don't see how duran is a top 4 greatest fighter of all time.

in fact it's a complete joke................

Foreman over Duran? Really?

[jrosales13]

LOL @ the Oscar argument. You have to be kidding me.