Who is boxing's most over rated fighter?

[#1Assassin]

Cotto is not overrated, we know he cant beat pacman, but all his other wins are legit, *** margs

Cotto isnt in his prime either, obviously

i disagree. canelo, williams, kirkland, lara, angulo and martirosyan all beat him, most if not all of them by KO. trout and molina would be 50/50 fights.

hes far from one of the best 154lbers in other words. hes shot, once arum stops protecting him his career will be over.

[Imatroll]

Floyd Mayweather

[SCtrojansbaby]

If the answer wasn't obvious before it is now you got ******** people saying that Cotto has a better resume than Castillo

[N!GGALAS CAGE]

Bute and Bradley.

[LeG00N]

right now? Cotto


he beat Mayorga and a 1 eye'd Margarito

and all of a sudden hes a top P4P ready for Pacquiao and Mayweather

[MRBOOMER]

Roman Gonzalez is indefeated and beat everyone infront of him.
Chris John is undefeated and hasn't lost to anyone infront of him.


All it has to do is with recognition. The super six fighters were made out to do mythical fighters who all were undefeated (except Kessler) and that they were P4P. Truth is the super six consisted of fighters who were made larger than they were. Ward has 2 good wins in Froch and Kessler but him beating Abraham and Green aren't big


think about it

Don't forget bika that was a solid win and Abraham and green were decent at best

[Thread Stealer]

Before 3 weeks ago, I'd say Amir Khan. I always would stretch my head at people who said they saw a future great when they watched him fight. But since fans are so harsh on people who lose, I'd no longer go with Khan ad most overrated.

I've always felt Sergio Martinez got overrated. People talked about him being up there with Pacquiao and Mayweather, with Max Kellerman talking about him being this "Superfighter". He's merely a good fighter in a poor division/era.

[RubenSonny]

Miguel Cotto I can't believe you people actually think he isn't washed up.

I actually agree with you, I think he stopped caring about legacy after the Pacquiao loss. I think everyone gets overrated and underrated but I find that the majority of people on this board overrate Cotto.

[Devils Advocate]

Chavez Jr or Bute. Atleast Chavez Jr's balls dropped and is atleast attempting to fight Rubio to fight Martinez if he wins. Bute thinks hes the best for some reason wants Wards sloppy seconds

I agree I hate the way he celebrates after his victories like they were not expected, like after the Zuniga and Miranda fight.

A close 2nd is Carlos Molina. I think he fought a Lara that had an off night and beat up a shot to shyt Cintron. Can't forget this guy has loses to Chavez Jr. and Alvardo so if he storks through Kirkland which I doubt much credit will then be deserved.

[William Blake]

Chavez Jr or Bute. Atleast Chavez Jr's balls dropped and is atleast attempting to fight Rubio to fight Martinez if he wins. Bute thinks hes the best for some reason wants Wards sloppy seconds

Chavez Jr.

Maybe Canelo.

They should fight.