Boxing fan ask Breadman "Would Pac beat Hearns, Leonard, Duran & Trinidad?"

[IMDAZED]

really? are you gonna make me rewatch everything?

I want you to watch them for the first time.

yes, want me to get corny? manny pacquiao one of the greatest fighters of all time, 8 division champion, considered best fighter in the world in his prime and blah blah...i can't bother

Yes. And at welter ranks well below Tito and a slew of others.

i dont know what you want me to say, the cotto is chinny is an opinion, and a senseless one at that with nothing to back it up.

Not sure it matters since Manny would be facing Tito, not Cotto.

[Doctor_Tenma]

well regardless, im thinking of the whitaker fight, whitaker about the size of manny, except pacquiao is bulkier, faster, stronger, maybe not as slick, but whitaker wasn't exactly being slick niether

that version of trinidad, i'd pick pacquiao by murder

No, Whitaker was physically stronger than Pacquiao, a past prime Whitaker managed to successfully man handle Tito at times and Manny is incapable of that. Also, Pernell could fight in the inside, may have been past it but he still had the kind of attributes that Manny lacks right now.

[SplitSecond]

I want you to watch them for the first time.

harsh

Yes. And at welter ranks well below Tito and a slew of others.

well he has accomplished less so it's understandable

Not sure it matters since Manny would be facing Tito, not Cotto.

you're the one that drove to that discussion not me, i was talkin to flicker

[SplitSecond]

No, Whitaker was physically stronger than Pacquiao, a past prime Whitaker managed to successfully man handle Tito at times and Manny is incapable of that. Also, Pernell could fight in the inside, may have been past it but he still had the kind of attributes that Manny lacks right now.

well i never said or am saying that manny would manhandle tito
but, yep, manny is incapable of that

fantasy is great
i dream you dream

[IMDAZED]

harsh

reality.

well he has accomplished less so it's understandable

No, he has a puncher's chance.

you're the one that drove to that discussion not me, i was talkin to flicker

Yeah, I drove that discussion by asking you how it relates to Tito. But regardless, you're out of answers.

[SplitSecond]

reality.

lol

No, he has a puncher's chance.

why are we even discussing, of all the discussions i've had with you, you always favor the bigger puncher and are usually very wrong in your predictions

Yeah, I drove that discussion by asking you how it relates to Tito. But regardless, you're out of answers.

well flicker brought it up for starters, not me, he said if chinny cotto can take pacquiao's punches why can't tito? well cotto hasn't been knocked down god knows how manny times, he also isn't as squared up as tito, was my answer and tito is like a left cross magnet

[IMDAZED]

why are we even discussing, of all the discussions i've had with you, you always favor the bigger puncher and are usually very wrong in your predictions

Sadly, this doesn't change what I've outlined here. Arguments like "he got hit a lot by Pernell Whitaker" (which he didn't) means you should watch fights before talking about them. Have you ever seen Pacquiao against the very dangerous Serikzhan Yeshmagambetov? Everyone gets hit.

well flicker brought it up for starters, not me, he said if chinny cotto can take pacquiao's punches why can't tito? well cotto hasn't been knocked down god knows how manny times, he also isn't as squared up as tito, was my answer

He also didn't take a punch as well as Tito, nor did he hit as hard as Tito, nor was he as good as Tito. Cotto hasn't been knocked down as many times? How many times has he been stopped? Knockdowns are subjective. He's also been hurt far more than Tito was. Only one person stopped Tito and that was Bernard Hopkins. I don't think Pacquiao, Cotto or anyone else at 147 could withstand his punches for 12 rounds.

[Light_Speed]

Cotto perforated Manny's ear drum with a big left hook. Tito's puncher's chance would be very high.

[adamdoyle]

ts said prime for prime,i think manny beats up tito

manny lands on tito chin early and jumps on him,he throws too many punches for tito to handle,tito's left hook would be missing all night long

Manny's a southpaw and like all southpaw's he is easily hit with right hands!
Tito had the best of his time! Biggest punching WW since hearns.
IMO stops Manny in the mid rounds of a war.

Leonard would be a complete mismatch as his better footwork/speed and hand speed would take Manny's entire game away

Hearns would be as much as a mismatch, his height and reach combined with speed and power would cripple Manny easily

And Duran is just JMM x100, a master boxer with "Hands of stone". I think he stops manny very easily

These men went on to win World titles in several higher weight classes and are all time greats! The hype that is manny pacquaio will fade in time!

[SplitSecond]

Sadly, this doesn't change what I've outlined here. Arguments like "he got hit a lot by Pernell Whitaker" (which he didn't) means you should watch fights before talking about them. Have you ever seen Pacquiao against the very dangerous Serikzhan Yeshmagambetov? Everyone gets hit.

who the ****??

He also didn't take a punch as well as Tito, nor did he hit as hard as Tito, nor was he as good as Tito. Cotto hasn't been knocked down as many times? How many times has he been stopped? Knockdowns are subjective. He's also been hurt far more than Tito was. Only one person stopped Tito and that was Bernard Hopkins. I don't think Pacquiao, Cotto or anyone else at 147 could withstand his punches for 12 rounds.

what do you mean he also didn't take a punch as well as tito, he got hit ****en hard vs mosley
tito would've gone down, held on and only survived because he lowblowed his way to the end of the round

i'd say cotto's chin is better although probabley not by much