Why is Oscar so underated on here?

[LeG00N]

Some good fighters, I think Oscar was good but How can I get his joke of a performance against Manny, that for me makes it impossible to call him ATG, Modern great (ie top 40 in last 2 decades) definately. The thing is, the alphabet soup we have today makes title's almost meaningless. Pacquiao looked tiny in there, but he was the only one fighting, the most one sided beat down in years.

you're judging Oscars career ... solely on the Pacquiao fight? what

[Integrital]

The only thing underrated about Oscar is how great his legs look in a pair of fishnet stockings.

Sinner.

[McGoorty]

More PROOF

neither's resume is better than Oscars and neither had more title defenses,Oscar has 2 atg's on his reusme(Whitaker,Chavez)

Your disdain for the Pacman is astounding, he was a FLYWEIGHT for your sake Mr. YAHWEY, Jupiter, Woden, Zeus, Buddha, Krishna or whoever you are, "strike me fat", PACQUIAO beats Jr MW's, WW's, LW's and he's a midget AND BEAT this "Golden Boy", Hah, lol, Ha ha, golden boy, that's a good one.:bukkake:

[McGoorty]

you're judging Oscars career ... solely on the Pacquiao fight? what

No, not JUST the Pacman fight, I said a bit more than that. I don't usually hold losses against a fighter, but could you ever imagine someone like Carmen Basilio getting KO'd by Manuel Ortiz (you heard of him ?) at any stage of his career. I'd like to hear your next effort.

[IronDanHamza]

Nice to see McGoorty getting his hands dirty in NSB!!

[EMACULATE]

Guy had a killer left hook and has a solid resume,champion in 6 different divisions.

Chavez-2 times
Whitaker
Vargas
Mayorga
Gatti
Quartey
Camacho
Miguel Angel Gonzalez
Genaro Hernandez
Felix Sturm


10 time champion,6 divisions

defended his wbc ww title 7 times and his wbo lw title 6 times

Oscar really should be rated higher but s few things hurt him. Whitaker fight, Sterm fight, Trinidad fight and the loss to Manny, Mosley and Floyd. I always had respect for Oscar because he fought everyone no matter if it was Hopkins, Mayweather, Whitaker, Trinidad, Mosley and Pacquaio. There isnt any fighter fighting today who has a better resume than that.

[McGoorty]

Oscar really should be rated higher but s few things hurt him. Whitaker fight, Sterm fight, Trinidad fight and the loss to Manny, Mosley and Floyd. I always had respect for Oscar because he fought everyone no matter if it was Hopkins, Mayweather, Whitaker, Trinidad, Mosley and Pacquaio. There isnt any fighter fighting today who has a better resume than that.

Pacquiao ???

[Pastrano]

Guy had a killer left hook and has a solid resume,champion in 6 different divisions.

Chavez-2 times
Whitaker
Vargas
Mayorga
Gatti
Quartey
Camacho
Miguel Angel Gonzalez
Genaro Hernandez
Felix Sturm


10 time champion,6 divisions

defended his wbc ww title 7 times and his wbo lw title 6 times

Youre opening Pandora's box! Dunno, I always wondered why there was such strong anti-Oscar sentiment not just here but on other boards as well. It really is astonishing and sad. Perhaps people just envy him too much, the man has it all.

[McGoorty]

Youre opening Pandora's box! Dunno, I always wondered why there was such strong anti-Oscar sentiment not just here but on other boards as well. It really is astonishing and sad. Perhaps people just envy him too much, the man has it all.

I'm happy for you.

[rambov]

Its because the fans on this site are to new to remember him.

Oscar was definitely one of the best out there.