more impressive roy goin from 154 to hw..or manny going from fly weight to ww

[puga]

Haye gained at fight night against who?

We are not talking about fight night weight, we are talking about scale weight.

i meant ruiz not haye.....you used scale weight ,atleast use it on both....

let's say ruiz gained 20lbs...so 154 to 246= 92 lbs

now, david haye fought from 190 to 316(valuve's just like you used ruiz)= 126

so again, based on you logic..haye is more impressive weight climber than roy....right?

i mean this is all based on your reasoing....

[cleaner147]

both impressive as ****...but

from jmw to hw = 6 divisions total

from from flw to ww = 9 divisions total

larry, is a horse bigger than an elephant?...

dont play dumb,

how many pounds is it from flyweight to super flyweight?

or from middleweight to SMW?

[puga]

Haye didn't win championships in multiple divisions like Roy

he did cruizer weight and hw dumb dumb....he climbd weight just like roy and pac ..

[puga]

dont play dumb,

how many pounds is it from flyweight to super flyweight?

or from middleweight to SMW?

read though the trhead mofo....ive explained it many times....

[-Spinal-]

ok cool...here

your reasoning is this :roy went up to more pouds than pac, thus he is more impressive in weight climbing than him

now, applying the same logic with haye...he fought from 190 to 316(valueve's weight just like you used ruiz's weight)= 126 lbs

so based on your logi, haye is more impressive than roy and pac, right?..

and that in oder for roy to match what haye did, he has to fight a guy as big as 280lbs(matching haye's 126)

right?...lol

Roy had it tougher than Pacquiao going up through weight classes, because he went up so many pounds but is only credited as 6 weight classes, winning titles in 4 of those, with no catchweights, only one vacant title and it was with a very good fighter in Hopkins.

Haye went up one weight class, but what weight has he dominated before going up to HW other CW.

Other than the 72lbs between 154-226, you have to add what Roy did in between that compared to what Haye did in between CW and HW. And Haye hasn't done much.

[puga]

Roy had it tougher than Pacquiao going up through weight classes, because he went up so many pounds but is only credited as 6 weight classes, winning titles in 4 of those, with no catchweights, only one vacant title and it was with a very good fighter in Hopkins.

Haye went up one weight class, but what weight has he dominated before going up to HW other CW.

Other than the 72lbs between 154-226, you have to add what Roy did in between that compared to what Haye did in between CW and HW. And Haye hasn't done much.

ok, let's eliminate those 2 weight classes whre pac fought at catchweights....ww, and lmw...that is still 2 weight classes weight more than roy.....8 total

so youre using difrent aprpoaches when comparing pac and roy ..and when comparing roy and haye

coz youre saying now roy is more impressive in weight claming than hay becasue he jumped more weight classes(whcih i agree)

but when comparing pac and roy, you do it difiretly by pounds...

lol

[Larry the boss]

floyds 3 retirements and countless tuneups.................and multiple ducks...........u

you are starting to worry me man......seriously how do you always manage to bring him up??no matter the thread..no matter the subject...hes on your mind

[Larry the boss]

puga in this thread

[JmH Reborn]

you are starting to worry me man......seriously how do you always manage to bring him up??no matter the thread..no matter the subject...hes on your mind

At first I was amused as well

Now I'm concerned

[LeG00N]

he did cruizer weight and hw dumb dumb....he climbd weight just like roy and pac ..

I didn't say he wasn't a multi divisional champion ....I said the weights he moved up he didnt conquer like roy or pacquiao ..