more impressive roy goin from 154 to hw..or manny going from fly weight to ww

[Mr. Invincible]

If Roy had retired after beating Tarver I he would have went down as a top 10 atg. Emanuel Steward even said it.

It was obvious Roy wasn't the same fighter after coming down. It's too bad his heart has stayed in it so long, now most boxing fans are begining to forget his greatness. Roy was Manny Pacquiao and Mayweather rolled into one.

There will never be another 'RJ'.

[puga]

Na, we can't do it like that. If you're going to mention Margarito's fight night weight, we have to mention Ruiz's fight night weight as well.

ok then do it.....so based on your logic , haye is more imprssive weight climber than both pac and roy.....right?

[-Spinal-]

LOL...i thought you said to do it fairly?

you used ruizs weight for roy but not margo's weight for pac...how's that doing it fairly?

John Ruiz weighed in at 226lbs on the scales, unofficially he came in heavier than that of course.


Antonio Margarito came in at 150lbs on the scale, he came in at 165lbs unofficially.


I was being fair, I was going by the scale weights, not the fight night weight. Scale weight for Ruiz: 226lbs, scale weight for Margarito: 150lbs.

[LeG00N]

both impressive as ****...but

from jmw to hw = 6 divisions total

from from flw to ww = 9 divisions total

larry, is a horse bigger than an elephant?...

yea the flyweights have like a thousand weights some are only separated by 3 pounds

[-Spinal-]

ok then do it.....so based on your logic , haye is more imprssive weight climber than both pac and roy.....right?

I'm not sure what you are trying to ask me.

I thought this was who's climb up in weights were more impressive between Roy and Pac?

[puga]

John Ruiz weighed in at 226lbs on the scales, unofficially he came in heavier than that of course.


Antonio Margarito came in at 150lbs on the scale, he came in at 165lbs unofficially.


I was being fair, I was going by the scale weights, not the fight night weight. Scale weight for Ruiz: 226lbs, scale weight for Margarito: 150lbs.

ok then do it......how much did ruiz gain at fight night?....is haye more impressive than pac and roy?....

[-Spinal-]

I can't find my Jones-Ruiz fight to look for the fight night weights. Not that it matters.

[-Spinal-]

ok then do it......how much did haye gain at fight night?....is haye more impressive than pac and roy?....

Haye gained at fight night against who?

We are not talking about fight night weight, we are talking about scale weight.

[puga]

I'm not sure what you are trying to ask me.

I thought this was who's climb up in weights were more impressive between Roy and Pac?

ok cool...here

your reasoning is this :roy went up to more pouds than pac, thus he is more impressive in weight climbing than him

now, applying the same logic with haye...he fought from 190 to 316(valueve's weight just like you used ruiz's weight)= 126 lbs

so based on your logi, haye is more impressive than roy and pac, right?..

and that in oder for roy to match what haye did, he has to fight a guy as big as 280lbs(matching haye's 126)

right?...lol

[LeG00N]

ok cool...here

your reasoning is this :roy went up to more pouds than pac, thus he is more impressive in weight climbing than him

now, applying the same logic with haye...he fought from 190 to 316(valueve's weight just like you used ruiz's weight)= 126 lbs

so based on your logi, haye is more impressive than roy and pac, right?..

and that in oder for roy to match what haye did, he has to fight a guy as big as 280lbs(matching haye's 126)

right?...lol

Haye didn't win championships in multiple divisions like Roy