more impressive roy goin from 154 to hw..or manny going from fly weight to ww

[puga]

lower weights are seperated by 4 pounds so miss me with dat ****.middle to light heavy is 15 pounds alone...try again son

right fullyso..coz 4 lbs to small guys eqautes to 7-8 lbs to a big guy.....get it?.....they designed those weightclasses based on that.....

[Luilun]

Roy!!! Due to the fact he didnt use a catch w8 BS!!!! Wish Roy woulda stayed at HW probably could have retired with all the belts at that time, instead he went down to LHW an messed his whole body up.

Fighting Ruiz was like a catch wieght it was like fighing the Heavywieght Champ of the special olympics

[Larry the boss]

Manny much more impressive Jones fought no one at Cruiser wieght and than fought John Ruiz to me wasn't the heavywieght Champ. If Jones had beaten Holyfield, Tyson or Bowe them type Heavies that it would have been Jones but since he cherry picked than to get Ko'd by Tarver and the other dude he looked like a complete cherry picken fool

was david diaz the lw champ???was margo the lmw champ??ok lets move on

[-Spinal-]

For Pacquiao to equal the amount of pounds Roy went up from 154-HW, startin from 106 he'd have to go up to Middleweight, no catchweights. Roy won his titles at the limit, no strings attached, no fighter cutting his arm off.

If people want to mention Manny being "short". Roy Jones is 5' 11", which is at best considered the average for Middleweights. At SMW already the average is 6-2. So Roy was basically a "short" LHW, and was even a shorter HW, but dominated 168-175 and shut out the lone HW he fought.

I'd say Roy.

[kadyo's]

Yea I think he could have at that time, I think he would have out boxed Lewis due to the fact he still had his speed and reflexes.

WoW!!!! you truly believe RJJ would out box Lennox?

WoW!!!!

[Larry the boss]

right fullyso..coz 4 lbs to small guys eqautes to 7-8 lbs to a big guy.....get it?.....they designed those weightclasses based on that.....

now you're gonna sit here and make up **** to justify your agenda..gotcha

[vcvc]

For Pacquiao to equal the amount of pounds Roy went up from 154-HW, startin from 106 he'd have to go up to Middleweight, no catchweights. Roy won his titles at the limit, no strings attached, no fighter cutting his arm off.

If people want to mention Manny being "short". Roy Jones is 5' 11", which is at best considered the average for Middleweights. At SMW already the average is 6-2. So Roy was basically a "short" LHW, and was even a shorter HW, but dominated 168-175 and shut out the lone HW he fought.

I'd say Roy.

this.....,,,

[kadyo's]

now you're gonna sit here and make up **** to justify your agenda..gotcha

You got your own agenda in creating this thread, larry, it's only fair. Each has his own agenda. LOL

[-Spinal-]

How many times did RJJ defend his heavyweight title?

How many times did pac defend his 150 lbs title?

I say it's a tie.

Roy won the title from the champion and top 10 HW John Ruiz, While Ruiz was not obligated to make any crazy catchweights.


Manny won his title while it was vacant, from a guy who was not even ranked in the top 15 at JMW, and not ranked at all at WW, and he did it with a catchweight.

[UglyPug]

both impressive as ****...but

from jmw to hw = 6 divisions total

from from flw to ww = 9 divisions total

larry, is a horse bigger than an elephant?...

yeah you are right at the end of the day both are accomplishments that might never be repeated. both very impressive in their own right; their careers have given us fans a lot.