Who will be remembered as the greater fighter: Manny Pacquiao or Bernard Hopkins?

[SCtrojansbaby]

Pacquiao hurt himself by basically wasting his last 7 fights going against guys who were either bums or totally shot

Clear wins over

Winky
Tarver
Johnson
Pavlik
Tito
Pascal

Are greater then

Barrera x2
Saskul
Ledwaba
Marquez(everybody knows Marquez actually won)
Shot Morales x2

[IronDanHamza]

pascal>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>shot mosley

tarver>>>>>>>>>>>>clottey

pavlik>>>>>>>>>>>>margo

tito>barerra

Don't be so ridiculous.

[IronDanHamza]

I would say Pacquaio to be slightly higher.

Not by much, though.

[tomhawq]

i'm a pac fan, but i don't mind fans giving props to other fighters. pac can take the backseat for all i care. all i care about is fights inside the ring, not some subjective rankings.

[Lords]

Pacquiao is fighting people on the decline coming off losses, while Bernard is fighting champions at 46 years of age and winning, this is a no brainer.

[Larry the boss]

Don't be so ridiculous.

why is that ridiculos??tito was an undefeated 3 division champ

[-MAKAVELLI-]

both are great fighters that we should feel blessed for being in our lifetime

[Chups]

Pacquiao hurt himself by basically wasting his last 7 fights going against guys who were either bums or totally shot

UNClear wins over

Winky (a small superwelter coming up to fight big bernard)
Tarver (weight drain from the movie Rocky 5, where he played a heavyweight)
Johnson
Pavlik (one dimensional fighter)
Tito (a welterweight)
Pascal (who?)

Are greater then

Barrera x2
Saskul
Ledwaba
Marquez(everybody knows Marquez actually won)
Shot Morales x2

If you wanna go that route

[SCtrojansbaby]

why is that ridiculos??tito was an undefeated 3 division champ

B-Hop resume is better then Pacquiaos but Barrera is clearly superior to Tito

[IronDanHamza]

why is that ridiculos??tito was an undefeated 3 division champ

Because Tito is an arguable ATG fighting in a weight class he wasn't too comfortable, and did very little in.

As opposed to Barrera who is a sure fire ATG who was fighting at a Division he was not only ranked #1 in, but quite possibly his best weight class.

Saying the Trinidad win is better than the Barrera win is absolutely false. Not even debatable.