Who will be remembered as the greater fighter: Manny Pacquiao or Bernard Hopkins?

[Larry the boss]

dude shot ass shane mosley is a better fighter than jean pascal in his prime , trained by eddie futch and doped up on steroids , epo and hgh.

pascal>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>shot mosley

tarver>>>>>>>>>>>>clottey

pavlik>>>>>>>>>>>>margo

tito>barerra

[Big Op]

bernard would cuz of his age...but what do i know

[JayDee2700]

Manny will, because he is the more popular fighter but in my IMHO! Bernard should be because what he is doing at his age is crazy! Manny wont do what Bernard is doin, Manny has about 1.5 to 2 good year left at max.

[Chups]

Where is the OPTION for BOTH??


They both will be remembered as legends.



Who is higher at the ATG list?

It's Pacquiao.

[Left Hook Tua]

pascal>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>shot mosley

tarver>>>>>>>>>>>>clottey

pavlik>>>>>>>>>>>>margo

tito>barerra

quit smoking dope.

this mofo took hopkins 4 best wins in his whole career and put it up against 1 of pacquiao's best wins and 3 so-so wins.


everyone is ****ting on pacquiao and floyd for cherry picking.

go list floyd and pac's last 4 opponents and go list bernard's.

[ИATAS]

Where is the OPTION for BOTH??


They both will be remembered as legends.



Who is higher at the ATG list?

It's Pacquiao.

Tunny is just creating polls that hopkins will lose in, he's being doing it since hopkins beat pascal, he even had one yesterday with the question: "who would win? Hopkins vs Klitschko"

He's a man on a mission right now! Everything he's doing is hopkins related and refuses to give hopkins a single ounce of credit for his accomplishments, it's embarrassing and shameful really.

[Left Hook Tua]

Manny will, because he is the more popular fighter but in my IMHO! Bernard should be because what he is doing at his age is crazy! Manny wont do what Bernard is doin, Manny has about 1.5 to 2 good year left at max.

since when did winning at an older age automatically make you greater?

you have foreman over ali because foreman won a title at an older age?

no. you still have to look at the entire resume.

[Ko King 212]

dude shot ass shane mosley is a better fighter than jean pascal in his prime , trained by eddie futch and doped up on steroids , epo and hgh.

Kill yourself.....

[AssasinKing]

Well what Hopkins has done is amazing, theres no doubt....but going by exactly who they had fights with and how they came out.... winner or loser

I gotta say pac.....the moving up in weight plus the competition, hes always faced pretty much the best out there....

Cant fault him

When you can win 12 rounds of a fight, and knock the other guy down, and STILL people wernt happy with what you did....that just shows how high the expectations are for this dude

[Chups]

Hopkins wins:

*Jean Pascal
*Roy Jones Jr.
*Kelly Pavlik
*Antonio Tarver
*Oscar De la Hoya
*Felix Trinidad
*Glen Johnson
*Winky Wright


20 Middleweight title defenses
Undisputed middleweight Champ
3 time World Champ in 2 different weightclasses
2 lineal titles


Pacquiao wins:

*Shane Mosley
*Miguel Cotto
*Ricky Hatton
*Oscar Dela Hoya
*Juan Manuel Marquez
*Erik Morales
*Erik Morales
*Marco Antonio Barrera
*Marco Antonio Barrera
*Oscar Larios
*Charchai Sasakul

3 fighters of the year Award
Fighter of the Decade Award
8 World titles in 8 different weightclass
4 lineal titles


Bolded indicates not a HOF but a very good Champ or lineal title holder.


Blue indicates HOF


It's close but still a no brainer!