Tweet
What if all 4 were in their prime, and had a tournament, who would come out on top? I know Katsidis is a lightweight, but just imagine him at 140.
All 4 are known for their exciting, no quit styles.
I think Hatton would come out on top, with Gatti being 2nd place, then Katsidis or Ward for 3rd.
edit:
as expected, most people are picking Hatton. To those who didn't choose Hatton, let's not forget that he only lost to the top 2 P4P fighters in Mayweather and Pacquiao. How would Gatti/Ward/Katsidis do against Mayweather and Hatton (we saw Gatti/Mayweather)?. Hatton fought Floyd at welterweight, one weightclass above his usual weight. Also, I still believe Hatton's chin was no longer the same after the Tszyu fight. He easily ate up the hard punching Tszyu's right hands. How was he able to take Tszyu's punches easily, then next he's getting hurt by Maussa and Collazo (I admit, Collazo is naturally about 2 weightclasses bigger than Hatton)? It's like Hatton left his chin in the Tszyu fight. Oh and there's also Hatton's lifestyle in between fights, gaining so much weight and losing it fast over and over would tax the body.
All 4 are known for their exciting, no quit styles.
I think Hatton would come out on top, with Gatti being 2nd place, then Katsidis or Ward for 3rd.
edit:
as expected, most people are picking Hatton. To those who didn't choose Hatton, let's not forget that he only lost to the top 2 P4P fighters in Mayweather and Pacquiao. How would Gatti/Ward/Katsidis do against Mayweather and Hatton (we saw Gatti/Mayweather)?. Hatton fought Floyd at welterweight, one weightclass above his usual weight. Also, I still believe Hatton's chin was no longer the same after the Tszyu fight. He easily ate up the hard punching Tszyu's right hands. How was he able to take Tszyu's punches easily, then next he's getting hurt by Maussa and Collazo (I admit, Collazo is naturally about 2 weightclasses bigger than Hatton)? It's like Hatton left his chin in the Tszyu fight. Oh and there's also Hatton's lifestyle in between fights, gaining so much weight and losing it fast over and over would tax the body.
Comment