Amir Khan and Marcos Maidana 1 and 2 in 140 lb

[Kagami Taiga]

So Bradley took Hatton's thrown and top Ring spot at JWW did he?

No, Pacman did, and remained the Ring champ at JWW for quite some time.

Don't bastardise the record books and reality. If at any time Manny may have given Bradley a shot at the top spot of JWW, he'd have been embarrassed and pushed even further back in the rankings.

oh so beating one guy makes u the man in the division??? gtfo...u make no sense and u dont kno wat u are talking about. hatton lost to pac, sure, but who else did pac fight in the division??? pac left, bradley was the man.

man u dudes are silly. khan best wins are maidana/koltenik. the other ppl u mentioned were not powerhouses at 140.

bradley's resume is better, the fact that u are arguing the point shows u havent been following 140.

[fallen9182]

1. Bradley
2/2A. Khan/Alexander
3. Maidana
4. Ortiz
5. Kotelnik/Peterson

[£-4-£]

Such a bias post...F'ing ridiculous.

Is not really comparable...Bradley resume is better at 140...

I mean really how is beating Salita better than beating Cherry or worse just as good as the Witter win?

Salita is a C-class opponent, but he took care of him impressively.

The OP didn't include Cherry. Cherry is better than Salita, but he's still a C-class fighter. Khan would wax him.

Witter was past-prime, I knew Bradley would beat him even though I'm a fan of Witter's.

Even if you score the Witter fight 9/10 on my scale, Khan still wins 35 to 34.

Khan's only had 4 fights at JWW so you can only score Bradley's 4 best wins at JWW, else it's not even.

[Kagami Taiga]

Salita is a C-class opponent, but he took care of him impressively.

The OP didn't include Cherry. Cherry is better than Salita, but he's still a C-class fighter. Khan would wax him.

Witter was past-prime, I knew Bradley would beat him even though I'm a fan of Witter's.

Even if you score the Witter fight 9/10 on my scale, Khan still wins 35 to 34.

Khan's only had 4 fights at JWW so you can only score Bradley's 4 best wins at JWW, else it's not even.

lol...so whats ur point??? who has the better resume at 140??? even if u include the maidana fight, bradleys resume is better. u can take out witter, bradleys resume is better. no matter how u cut it, bradleys resume is better. bradley is fighting alexander next month, bradley beats him, bradley's resume at 140 is wayyyyy better.

wat it all boils down to is....bradleys resume is better.

[TheKza]

Khan is joint top with Bradley and Maidana 2nd, as Khan just got the best win out of any 140 fighter on his record. I heard Maidana-Berto(FINGERS CROSSED). Bradley has to beat Devon to officialy take that numero uno.

[Kris Silver]

oh so beating one guy makes u the man in the division??? gtfo...u make no sense and u dont kno wat u are talking about. hatton lost to pac, sure, but who else did pac fight in the division??? pac left, bradley was the man.

man u dudes are silly. khan best wins are maidana/koltenik. the other ppl u mentioned were not powerhouses at 140.

bradley's resume is better, the fact that u are arguing the point shows u havent been following 140.

Fighters recognized as champions by The Ring are rated at the top of their division, with the top 10 contenders listed below.

The only three occasions when a fighter will lose his championship status are when he retires, moves to another weight division, or is defeated in a championship bout.

I copied that from the Ring website, by far the most respected and followed rankings in the sport, as you clearly seem to not follow that too much and prefer to have your own idea and try to instill it as fact.

Oh and for the record, Manny did not leave the division per say, for quite some time indeed. He would have entertained big fights there, had there been a worthy enough opponent. Yup, but that adds salt to the wound, doesn't it.

[mrgreenfingers]

how about

1. Bradley
2. Khan
3. Kotelnik
4. Alexander
5. Maidana

swap round alexander with kotelnik if you think his win over him was legit

[£-4-£]

lol...so whats ur point??? who has the better resume at 140??? even if u include the maidana fight, bradleys resume is better. u can take out witter, bradleys resume is better. no matter how u cut it, bradleys resume is better. bradley is fighting alexander next month, bradley beats him, bradley's resume at 140 is wayyyyy better.

wat it all boils down to is....bradleys resume is better.

Khan's win over Maidana is better than any of Bradley's wins FFS.

Bradley's top-3 wins:
Prime-Holt (UD), Prime-Peterson (UD), Past-Prime Witter (SD. A prime-Witter would have won though).

Khan's top-3 wins:
Prime-Kotelnik (UD), Malignaggi (TKO 11), Prime-Maidana (UD).


Peterson and Holt aren't all that. Kotelnik beats them both by UD, and Maidana stops them both.

[Kagami Taiga]

Fighters recognized as champions by The Ring are rated at the top of their division, with the top 10 contenders listed below.

The only three occasions when a fighter will lose his championship status are when he retires, moves to another weight division, or is defeated in a championship bout.

I copied that from the Ring website, by far the most respected and followed rankings in the sport, as you clearly seem to not follow that too much and prefer to have your own idea and try to instill it as fact.

Oh and for the record, Manny did not leave the division per say, for quite some time indeed. He would have entertained big fights there, had there been a worthy enough opponent. Yup, but that adds salt to the wound, doesn't it.

dude...just shut up and quit the site. no1 is talking about who's the ring champion. im not even talking about whos the lineal champ. im talking about who was the best in the division. after hatton lost to pac, tim bradley was the man to beat in the division. sure things have got more interesting but bradley is still the man. why are u even arguing that???

[jrosales13]

]Khan's win over Maidana is better than any of Bradley's wins FFS. [/B]

Bradley's top-3 wins:
Prime-Holt (UD), Prime-Peterson (UD), Past-Prime Witter (SD. A prime-Witter would have won though).

Khan's top-3 wins:
Prime-Kotelnik (UD), Malignaggi (TKO 11), Prime-Maidana (UD).


Peterson and Holt aren't all that. Kotelnik beats them both by UD, and Maidana stops them both.

How so? Because, he beat Ortiz? Because, he barely edged out a shot to **** "Chop Chop"? Because, he beat Cayo? WTF made Maidana win better than any Bradley win?