Amir Khan and Marcos Maidana 1 and 2 in 140 lb

[Kagami Taiga]

Khan's win over Maidana is better than any of Bradley's wins FFS.

Bradley's top-3 wins:
Prime-Holt (UD), Prime-Peterson (UD), Past-Prime Witter (SD. A prime-Witter would have won though).

Khan's top-3 wins:
Prime-Kotelnik (UD), Malignaggi (TKO 11), Prime-Maidana (UD).


Peterson and Holt aren't all that. Kotelnik beats them both by UD, and Maidana stops them both.

so u compare resumes by looking at the top 3 opponenets?? riiiiite...u dudes are trying too hard. lol, i give up...

[FloydTBE]

bradley is number 1

[jrosales13]

Salita is a C-class opponent, but he took care of him impressively.

The OP didn't include Cherry. Cherry is better than Salita, but he's still a C-class fighter. Khan would wax him.

Witter was past-prime, I knew Bradley would beat him even though I'm a fan of Witter's.

Even if you score the Witter fight 9/10 on my scale, Khan still wins 35 to 34.

Khan's only had 4 fights at JWW so you can only score Bradley's 4 best wins at JWW, else it's not even.

Exactly so your scales sucks...

And, so what that Khan only has 4 fights at JWW, Why only score Bradley 4 fights is not his fault? We're talking about 140 resume...You have to judge their whole 140 resume not one guy whole resume and then the portion of the other guy...

I mean Alexander can go to 147 fight once and when compare him resume at 147 with Pac and Floyd we can only get one fight from Pac and Floyd? I mean WTF that makes no sense.

[the niggest]

1 Bradley
2 Alexander
3 Amir Khan
4 Marcos Maidana
5 Ortiz/Peterson/Kotelnik

How can you put Alexander above Khan?

Alexander's resume: Junior Witter, Juan Urango, Kotelnik(which was pretty much a hometown decision)

Khan's resume: Kotelnik, Malignaggi, Maidana

Bradley is still number 1... But not by THAT much. Khan's resume is shaping up at 140.

Khan is 2nd, anyone who argues against that is a hater. No way in hell Alexander is above him.

Alexander at 3 place.

[£-4-£]

How so? Because, he beat Ortiz? Because, he barely edged out a shot to **** "Chop Chop"? Because, he beat Cayo? WTF made Maidana win better than any Bradley win?

As I stated earlier, Maidana was a nightmare match-up for Khan, and Khan won. Bradley hasn't fought anybody as dangerous to him as Maidana is to Khan...

He beat a top-10 contender in Ortiz. If Bradley beat Ortiz then everybody would be d*ck-riding him, singing his praises and announcing him as the second coming of Jesus (Cesar Chavez that is)!!!!

The only reason he didn't KO Chop chop Corley is because he was poorly conditioned in that fight and gassed.

FACT: Maidana is better than Peterson and Holt.

[Kagami Taiga]

As I stated earlier, Maidana was a nightmare match-up for Khan, and Khan won. Bradley hasn't fought anybody as dangerous to him as Maidana is to Khan...

He beat a top-10 contender in Ortiz. If Bradley beat Ortiz then everybody would be d*ck-riding him, singing his praises and announcing him as the second coming of Jesus (Cesar Chavez that is)!!!!

The only reason he didn't KO Chop chop Corley is because he was poorly conditioned in that fight and gassed.

FACT: Maidana is better than Peterson and Holt.

listen to this guy...

[jrosales13]

As I stated earlier, Maidana was a nightmare match-up for Khan, and Khan won. Bradley hasn't fought anybody as dangerous to him as Maidana is to Khan...

Not true, Khan was the favorite by 3 or 31/2 to 1 against Maidana. Bradley was the underdog going into the Witter fight and went all the way to the U.K to fight him in the champ turf...Now that is impressive.

And, if you talking about punching power Holt probably hit just as hart as Maidana.

He beat a top-10 contender in Ortiz. If Bradley beat Ortiz then everybody would be d*ck-riding him, singing his praises and announcing him as the second coming of Jesus (Cesar Chavez that is)!!!!

Well not true again, because Bradley beat better fighters than Ortiz already.

And, who did Ortiz beat to become a top 10 contender?

The only reason he didn't KO Chop chop Corley is because he was poorly conditioned in that fight and gassed.

Are you making excuses? Jose Alfaro KO'd Chop Chop in 5 rounds WTF was Chop Chop doing their long enough to "gas out" a "dangerous" "puncher" in Maidana? GTFOH Maidana is just not as good as you trying to make him out to be.

FACT: Maidana is better than Peterson and Holt.

No, that is not a fact that is an opinion dummy, do you know the difference?

[Kris Silver]

dude...just shut up and quit the site. no1 is talking about who's the ring champion. im not even talking about whos the lineal champ. im talking about who was the best in the division. after hatton lost to pac, tim bradley was the man to beat in the division. sure things have got more interesting but bradley is still the man. why are u even arguing that???

Incapable of discussing and making any kind of point rationally aren't you. You throw out logical meaningful points in exchange for your meaningless ranting subjective crap.

Did Bradley beat the guy whom for actual years, had been considered the king at JWW, and had been Ring champ like it or not, people do follow?

For the best part of a year since Bradley beating Witter, did he reach the top spot in the division as you so proclaim?

The answer to both is simply no. No matter how badly you wish see it otherwise, ignore the respected ranking organisation for boxing (not you) and the actual facts.

At any time Pacman was still considered active in the division, was Bradley ranked the top guy there? No. I bet you have no idea when that was either.

He didn't take any crown's hat at the weight hence not being it's champ, nor the Ring champ, and has only really been #1 for 1 year+.

Even then that could all change very soon.

No matter how much you like the try to tweak fact, that's it above. Now suck it, grow up, communicate maturely and objectively.

[mellow_mood]

disagree.....

1- bradley
2- devon

should be the top 2....

[mellow_mood]

bradley is number 1

thats about to change!!!

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR DEVON!!!!!!