Has Floyd beaten anyone who is as good as a prime Cotto?

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

Diego Corralles
Genaro Hernandez
Zab Judah
Jose Luis Castillo

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

That cotto vs Shane fight was draw.

I scored it a draw. If didn't then that's on you. But you the same dude who had Alexander up Dam near 10 rounds against kotelnik.

[AKATheMack]

How many fighters have Cotto beaten that could beat a Prime Mayweather?

None at all. Im not attacking Mayweather or his resume, but people completely change the question to enforce their opinion. I think not taking Cottos 0 is possibly the biggest mistake Mayweather has made as a professional.

[Brockton Lip]

P4P then I'd say yes but if I assume we're not talking about that so I voted no. People are saying Hernandez and Castillo, etc, but they would never beat a prime Cotto. Its a toss up between Cotto and Oscar but I think Cotto would have too much for him.

[Ragnar Lothbrok]

None at all. Im not attacking Mayweather or his resume, but people completely change the question to enforce their opinion. I think not taking Cottos 0 is possibly the biggest mistake Mayweather has made as a professional.

he'll make up for it by taking berto's "0"




Floyd & Carl will make up for it now....


not really.

[MXboxingfan]

Was Cotto in his prime when he fought Pacquaio despite the fact that he had already taken a beating from the the plaster of paris?

[Gorilla Dogs]

Cotto gets overrated too much on these forums. PPl just fall in love with his "at the time" perfect record.


Cotto is a B + fighter Floyd and manny are A+

[Iceta Lives]

Cotto is overrated as hell. Not as much as he used to be, but still overrated nontheless.

[BMWM3P]

I'll also add that Cotto gets KO'd by the Oscar that Floyd fought.

LOL talk about a raving nuthugger. Floyd has never beat anyone as good as Cotto.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

So wait the thread turned from to who was "as good as Cotto" to "who would beat him on Floyds resume"?

Now were brining styles and weight into the equasion. Cmon people.