Would Evander beat Toney if Evander was in his prime?

[TheGreat1]

i'm a huge Toney Fan, but there is no way in hell he could beat Holy in Holy's prime.

[Stealthic]

Holy was a damn good boxer in his prime, not just a swarmer. He used to move and jab with the best of them. I think he'd have wiped the floor with "Lights Out".

[Leo Pradun]

I think it would be a pretty easy win if Holyfield was in his prime...

What are your opinions?

offcorse Holyfield gets the easy win...

[jack_the_rippuh]

I respect the opinion of the people who say they think Holyfield would win, but by stoppage....I doubt it. Like I said in my post, I think he would UD Toney.

[Mike Tyson Jr.]

if dave tiberi whooped his
ass. holyfield in his prime
would definitely whoop toneys
steroid using ass

[Tha_Greatest]

I agree with Finesse,Evander by UD,but it will be a lopsided one sided win for Evander, cause Toney is out of shape and needs steroids, Toney fans, dont get angry, only my opinion

[Ali_is_the_greatest17]

I respect the opinion of the people who say they think Holyfield would win, but by stoppage....I doubt it. Like I said in my post, I think he would UD Toney.

Has Toney ever been KOed or TKOed?

[Tha_Greatest]

Has Toney ever been KOed or TKOed?

Im not sure but i honestly think he has,by Montell Griffin, he lost to Montell 2 times and i remember seeing a clip of Toney going down to Montell, im not sure if it was a knock down or knock out

[FistoftheDallasStar]

This one is tough question to answer mainly because James Toney wasn't in his prime during the Holyfield fight... That being said if a prime Holyfield was fighting the exact same James Toney it would go to the score cards and the "Real Deal" would survive the vicious counters of James and could possible ekk out a close decision. Only because Holy's recuperative prowess would come in effect but Holy chin was able to be rocked even in his prime evidence of his bouts with Smokin' Bert Cooper and Bowe. I don't think Holyfield would be able to KO Toney though he has a solid chin and even took some of Evanders best punches in their "real" bout. It's all about timing and James caught Holy in the best time for a KO. Don't forget James may have a big mouth that turns fans off but you can't underestimate his skill he really is the definition of the word "veteran savy".

[Memorex]

theres no way in hell toney beats holy is his prime, holy ko's him within 10 rounds