Would Evander beat Toney if Evander was in his prime?

**theironone** · 08-02-2005, 11:42 AM

Yeh Holy would win, he'd outwork him

**marvdave** · 08-02-2005, 11:44 AM

wouldn't be "easy", but Holy would have too much activity and stamina for the fatboy.

Probably a unanimous decision for Holy

**DiegoFuego** · 08-02-2005, 12:04 PM

No way Holyfield beats Toney, even in his prime. Nah uh

**MetalVomit** · 08-02-2005, 12:06 PM

Originally posted by Ali_is_the_greatest17

I think it would be a pretty easy win if Holyfield was in his prime...

What are your opinions?

Holyfield in his prime would give Toney no chance to counter him. All the slipping punches and head movement would be good to frustrate Evander, but in his prime, the guy was a machine.

**Ali_is_the_greatest17** · 08-02-2005, 12:07 PM

Originally posted by marvdave

wouldn't be "easy", but Holy would have too much activity and stamina for the fatboy.

Probably a unanimous decision for Holy

I know...James Toney was too out of shape for Holyfield..

**MetalVomit** · 08-02-2005, 12:08 PM

Originally posted by DiegoFuego

No way Holyfield beats Toney, even in his prime. Nah uh

Have you ever seen Holyfield in his prime? You honestly believe Toney would be able to keep up with the constant pressure and combinations upstairs and down? Holyfield was a beast in his prime and he would simply overwhelm Toney.

**riz** · 08-02-2005, 12:16 PM

u kno when the thread was loading n i saw that diego fuego was replying, how did i know that he wold say that toney would beat holyfield

have u seen holyfield, holy **** the man was unstoppable. i mean he moved up to heavyweight b4 he lost his first fight.

in his twelfth fight he fought for the WBA cruiserweight belt n won in 15 rounds

he defends it 4 times b4 he moves up to heavyweight, and beats alex steward n KO'd buster douglas in 3.
then beats foreman and holmes, b4 losing to bowe.
after beating alex steward for the 2nd time, he beats bowe in a very tough close fight.
after losing tough losses to moorer and bowe, he KO'd mike tyson in fight of the year
then beats moorer in a rematch, and also vaughn bean.
taht was when his career started to take a tumble

so at that point holfiled loss to, bowe, and moorer.

toney has lost to RJJ which is fine
but montell griffin TWICE, and also sum no name ****

**Ali_is_the_greatest17** · 08-02-2005, 12:36 PM

Originally posted by riz

u kno when the thread was loading n i saw that diego fuego was replying, how did i know that he wold say that toney would beat holyfield

have u seen holyfield, holy **** the man was unstoppable. i mean he moved up to heavyweight b4 he lost his first fight.

in his twelfth fight he fought for the WBA cruiserweight belt n won in 15 rounds

he defends it 4 times b4 he moves up to heavyweight, and beats alex steward n KO'd buster douglas in 3.
then beats foreman and holmes, b4 losing to bowe.
after beating alex steward for the 2nd time, he beats bowe in a very tough close fight.
after losing tough losses to moorer and bowe, he KO'd mike tyson in fight of the year
then beats moorer in a rematch, and also vaughn bean.
taht was when his career started to take a tumble

so at that point holfiled loss to, bowe, and moorer.

toney has lost to RJJ which is fine
but montell griffin TWICE, and also sum no name ****

Man...you sure know a whole lot of history about Holyfield.

**Easy-E** · 08-02-2005, 12:54 PM

Originally posted by GodzHand

Holyfield in his prime would give Toney no chance to counter him. All the slipping punches and head movement would be good to frustrate Evander, but in his prime, the guy was a machine.

prime holyfield was good, no denying it, but evander was far from a machine. anyone who loses to rid**** bowe is not a machine. if holyfield has a good night, he wins by ud, but if he isnt in the best shape and doesnt bring his game, toney could definitly win

Would Evander beat Toney if Evander was in his prime?