Who would you rank higher All-Time P4P; Duran, Pacquiao, or Chavez

[T.McGrady]

Duran

Pacman

Chavez

[talip bin osman]

if duran decided back then to retire after his adventures in lightweight, i would think he would rate higher still than the other two...

but thats just me...

[turdleburgle]

pacquiao is greater than all three.he would never have lost to guys like sims and laing and he would never quit either.duran was great but pac has the greater resume.


chavez was also great but a level below pac and duran

[talip bin osman]

pacquiao is greater than all three.he would never have lost to guys like sims and laing and he would never quit either.duran was great but pac has the greater resume.


chavez was also great but a level below pac and duran

but he did lose to singsurat and torrecampo...

[-EX-]

Idk but Duran is ahead of them...

[led]

pac is still active fighter. how can u rank him?

[pasawayako]

p4p....

1. Manny Pacquuiao (elite SFW, SBW, FW, LW, JW, WW)
2. Roberto Duran (elite LW, WW)
3. Julio Cesar Chavez (elite JWW)

So if this is p4p then it's Manny Pacquiao by a country mile. He has proven himself to be an elite fighter in 6 Different weight classes whereas Duran has been elite in two and Chavez in one.

With this evidence? Pacquiao by far.

[turdleburgle]

but he did lose to singsurat and torrecampo...

he was a kid and nowhere near his best.

[talip bin osman]

he was a kid and nowhere near his best.

same with duran but in reverse...

when laing and simms beat duran, he was a shot old man with his best days behind him...

[Heru]

When it's all said and done, it's going to end up Duran-Pacquiao-Chavez.