Who really won the first Mayweather v Castillo fight?

[NesNY]

HBO announcers

"wow. that's not the fight we just saw".

I think Lederman scored it correctly.

[BoxerDood]

I think Floyd edged it 7 rounds to 5. He clearly took the first four, and he stole three at the end. He did pretty good considering he fought with one hand and it was his first fight at 135.

And compubox scores don't always mean a fighter won. If that was the case, then Daniel Jacobs was ahead 40-36 before the KO last Saturday.

[War Dinamita]

Castillo won the first fight and Floyd won the rematch.

Manny lost twice to JMM and ducked him for a 3rd fight. Floyd gave Castillo an immediate rematch instead of ducking him like Manny ducked JMM for years.

[The Big Dunn]

it was a very close fight...but mayweather haters steady claim that castillo beat him down...and floyd really impressed me by fighting through that shoulder injury and fighting castillo his first fight at 135.

If someone truly believe Castillo won this fight and you can't hate them for it. The thing is this is the one fight floyd had that was close so he had to lose. Robbery is Sweet Pea vs. Ramirez. This was no robbery. Besides, Castillo got a 2nd change and floyd was healthy.

[pistol whip]

wow. It must really suck when a fighter someone hates wins a close fight with a broken hand (for 7 rds) at a higher weight class. VEry close fight, as close as williams martinez. I thought judges had it right!

Yeah they had it so right that the judges scored the second fight closer than the first fight. Come on Dunn everyday I have a harder time believing that you even watch boxing on a regular basis. Come on my friend there is a world of boxing outside of Floyd.

[infamous larryx]

jesus christ.....4real..i mean 4real??are you and cungle the same person??

[infamous larryx]

like it or not..floyds 41-0..no matter how much you complain and post this tired thread over and over and over again..floyds 41-0

[The Big Dunn]

Yeah they had it so right that the judges scored the second fight closer than the first fight. Come on Dunn everyday I have a harder time believing that you even watch boxing on a regular basis. Come on my friend there is a world of boxing outside of Floyd.

Pistol the 2nd fight has nothing to do with this one. You can diss me all you want. Floyd won both fights IMO. If you disagree fine with me.

[pistol whip]

Castillo won the first fight and Floyd won the rematch.

Manny lost twice to JMM and ducked him for a 3rd fight. Floyd gave Castillo an immediate rematch instead of ducking him like Manny ducked JMM for years.

Yeah theres more to the story than this but thanks for leaving out all the details so floyd could be made to look like he has the heart of a lion.

[pistol whip]

Pistol the 2nd fight has nothing to do with this one. You can diss me all you want. Floyd won both fights IMO. If you disagree fine with me.

Im just trying to point out th ******ity of the judging to you. Second fight was a clear win for Floyd and it was judged closer than the first fight that in my opinion was razor ***ing close.

Even you can understand why people are upset about the first one.