Is having 0 losses what makes a great fighter?

[mushahadeen]

JCC Jr. would be a great fighter even if he was 0-42. But the fact that he is 42-0 makes him one of the greatest of all time.

[Spoon23]

Spoon I never said floyd was the greatest did I? I never said he doesn't have to prove himself. I asked you who he should have fought that he didn't. Thats all.

You think its about legacy. About having us diehards call him an ATG. I think you are being incredibly naive. This is a business plain and simple. Ali, robinson, leonard fought the guys who brought them the most money plain and simple. They didn't fight tough guys for the sake of it.

I think its about earning the most money possible on your job. Perhaps of different opinions reflect where we are in life.

Don't have to answer what you ask coz it is out of context. Disproving my reply just says that you think he is the atg. Even if you try to not say it is so. I just nailed you and your ass is squirming like alittle girl.. Geez I know your a ***** so please try to act like one hehe. You love him to death.

[Mitch5]

Grow some braincells first lol.. I just can't understand why you think Floyd has proven himself to say he has reached the cieling of greatness, and can be called the greatest of all time.

Ask yourself that, and you will see enlightenment. But if you say yes.. Your defiintely 'still' in the ***** world where every gayweather says is right

I'm talking about legacy if you can say he has nothing left to prove and he is the ATG. Then prove it. I want you to put a thread on why he is the best!

And you know what, sad to say I have a feeling there's going to be alot of bashers going in there coz Floyd ain't all that yet.. at least for now until he steps up to the plate and be the Gorilla that he thinks he is.

It's called "LEGACY"

Please post a thread on why your fighter is THE GREATEST, I can't wait to read it.

The reason people believe floyd is a great fighter is because of the fights he had at 130 and 135 and his great skill set where he took on anybody who wanted to fight him.

[Spoon23]

Spoon I never said floyd was the greatest did I? I never said he doesn't have to prove himself. I asked you who he should have fought that he didn't. Thats all.

You think its about legacy. About having us diehards call him an ATG. I think you are being incredibly naive. This is a business plain and simple. Ali, robinson, leonard fought the guys who brought them the most money plain and simple. They didn't fight tough guys for the sake of it.

I think its about earning the most money possible on your job. Perhaps of different opinions reflect where we are in life.

This is also a sport where we admire athletes and heroes. It's not all about money. If it is all about money i'll be a hired killer. Life is about legacy and having money goes hand in hand. To be called great you need to do something great. Why dispute that?

I swear you *****s are getting really ******ed..

[Tyson.]

Mayweather is a great fighter and arguably the best skilled fighter of all time.

His ducking of fighters is what will lead to him not being ranked up there with Ali and SRR. Still though for what he has achieved he is a top 50 ATG.

[The Big Dunn]

Don't have to answer what you ask coz it is out of context. Disproving my reply just says that you think he is the atg. Even if you try to not say it is so. I just nailed you and your ass is squirming like alittle girl.. Geez I know your a ***** so please try to act like one hehe. You love him to death.

What? are you really serious? So I ask a question which you are afraid to answer so you decide you can win by calling me a *****. I apologize i thought you were a serious poster looking for a good debate. if you ever feel like answering the questions let me know.

[The Big Dunn]

This is also a sport where we admire athletes and heroes. It's not all about money. If it is all about money i'll be a hired killer. Life is about legacy and having money goes hand in hand. To be called great you need to do something great. Why dispute that?

I swear you *****s are getting really ******ed..

If you don't think that floyd's career is great then you are entitled to that opinion. If you think fighting manny makes his career greater I don't disagree. Where we disgree is you think manny wants this fight as a test of skills more than he wants $35 mil.

If this is so, why not fight Bradley instead of cotto 2 ormarg if the floyd fight falls through?

[Spoon23]

What? are you really serious? So I ask a question which you are afraid to answer so you decide you can win by calling me a *****. I apologize i thought you were a serious poster looking for a good debate. if you ever feel like answering the questions let me know.

Yup say what you want. This was my post and I have been so clear with my replies to you but still I can't fathom why you don't get it..One logically explanation your a Floyd fan who can't take the heat..

[Spoon23]

If you don't think that floyd's career is great then you are entitled to that opinion. If you think fighting manny makes his career greater I don't disagree. Where we disgree is you think manny wants this fight as a test of skills more than he wants $35 mil.

If this is so, why not fight Bradley instead of cotto 2 ormarg if the floyd fight falls through?

Who said bradley is better than cotto or margarito? Bradley has to prove himself. It's called corporate ladder.

It's fictional to say he is the greatest it applies to any fighter saying he is. To where you are and your standings is to have your records and credentials good enough to command a match with a great opponent.

We won't even be thinking of Bradley, cotto or margacheato if Floyd would just sign the contract.

Why can't you as a floyd fan just say damn I wish floyd would sign the contract already I want a good fight. Why are you guys putting road blocks for floyd.

As a boxing fan, we should embrace this fight to happen. **** money it's all about entertaining us and putting a good show for the sport.

So why not cooperate and make it happen for all the fans wether *****s or *******s.. Why hate..

Fight is what fuels in being in this website.

[Spoon23]

If you don't think that floyd's career is great then you are entitled to that opinion. If you think fighting manny makes his career greater I don't disagree. Where we disgree is you think manny wants this fight as a test of skills more than he wants $35 mil.

If this is so, why not fight Bradley instead of cotto 2 ormarg if the floyd fight falls through?

Who said bradley is better than cotto or margarito? Bradley has to prove himself. It's called corporate ladder.

It's fictional to say he is the greatest it applies to any fighter saying he is. To where you are and your standings is to have your records and credentials good enough to command a match with a great opponent.

We won't even be thinking of Bradley, cotto or margacheato if Floyd would just sign the contract.

Why can't you as a floyd fan just say damn I wish floyd would sign the contract already I want a good fight. Why are you guys putting road blocks for floyd.

As a boxing fan, we should embrace this fight to happen. **** money it's all about entertaining us and putting a good show for the sport.

So why not cooperate and make it happen for all the fans wether *****s or *******s.. Why hate..

Boxing Fights are what fuels us in being in this website.