Who Has The Better Resume?

[Toney616]

how is beatin barrera and gettin a close contraversial decision over marquez better than floyd beatin genaro hernadez and jesus chavez

What has Chavez done? Barerra (a little past prime) is a first ballot hofer, its a great win for pac. Hernadez was past prime and retired after that fight. Pac should of been given a 10-6 lead after the first round with jmm, which they didn't do.
Barrera+Marquez>hernadez+Chavez

[Gutz]

Pac resume is better then Floyd..

give it up *****s..



This is the reason why Pac won FOTD and Floyd didnt..

[The Big Dunn]

Fair enough

Did you score the fight yourself and if you did can you post up your scorecard?

True, Pac should get flack for waiting so long before giving jmm a rematch

I think I scored it 7-5-1 to Castillo, when I find my scorecard ill post it up, maybe tomorrow. Castillo dominated from rounds 5 onwards, he was more active, the agressor and landed the harder clean punches imo.
To quote Lampley after the scorecards were read, "that's not the fight we just watched"

Giving counter-punchers a rematch is always a bad idea, especially if they have figured out your style, but it doesn't make up for the bad decision from their first fight

Thats the thing about the castillo fights. Floyd moved up in weight and fought a guy this site ranked as one of the 25 greatest ever at the weight. Inthe 1st fight floyd won 5-7 rds depending how you scored it. Next fight he won 10-12 rds depending.

When you move up and beat the top dog in no worse than 70% of the rds that impressive.

[Mr. Fantastic]

Based on names it's Pac.

[ummeed]

non of those 3 were coming off of shut out loses at a higher weight..oscar just ko's mayorga,shane just ko's margo..and jmm just ko'd juan diaz

roy jones just tko'd lacy before fighting danny green, does that mean he wasn't shot?

[infamous larryx]

Pac resume is better then Floyd..

give it up *****s..



This is the reason why Pac won FOTD and Floyd didnt..

yep..cause floyd retired and said **** everyone..thats why manny won

[qwerty07]

What has Chavez done? Barerra (a little past prime) is a first ballot hofer, its a great win for pac. Hernadez was past prime and retired after that fight. Pac should of been given a 10-6 lead after the first round with jmm, which they didn't do.
Barrera+Marquez>hernadez+Chavez

The judge even acknowledged the mistake afterwards. Pac/JMM H2H would have been 2-0. How *****s thought pac lost BOTH, is funny to say the least.

[F l i c k e r]

I think you are having a harder time convincing yourself that Mayweather has a good resume than convincing others, because it's so insane what you're saying.


1-corrales-former champ at 130 p4p top 5 Legit win
2-mosley-wba champ p4p#3 40 year old grandpa, 1.5 years inactivity, gassed after second round
3-hatton-linear lww champ,former wba ww champ top 5 p4p bloated
4-oscar-wbc lmw champ way past his prime, same when Pac fought him
5-hernendez-#1 at 130 wbc champ Who?
6-judah-former linear champ at ww beaten by Tszyu who mayweather ducked, lost to spinks and baldy JUST BEFORE mayweather bout
7-gatti-wbc lww champ past his prime, wasn't an impressive win
8-castillo-wbc lw champ lost the first bout, won the second
9-baldo-linear ww champ destroyed by clottey in his prime before DQ, old and fat vs mayweather
10-jmm-linear lw champ-p4p#2 OMG, you had to mention this fatty?

So yeah, not so impressive when you really analyze it.

This is kinda ignorant. Because you can nit pick at Pacquiao's best wins too.

MAB: Good win
EM x3: Lost one, won 2 against shot, old and drained morales
JMM x2: 1 loss, 1 win(disputable)
Hatton: If mayweather fought a **** version, pacquiao fought a worse version
Clottey: Doesn't punch back, gatekeeper, nobody
ODLH: If mayweather fought a **** version, pacquiao fought a drained **** version
Cotto: Drained and shot.

So what, he only had 1 legit win?

[letsgobrady]

non of those 3 were coming off of shut out loses at a higher weight..oscar just ko's mayorga,shane just ko's margo..and jmm just ko'd juan diaz

exactly,oscar just came off a fight where he looked like **** against forbes,ricky looked okay against paulie but paulie looked bad and right before the paulie fight ricky looked like he was about to get knocked down by lazcano,miguel just came off of a fight with clottey that alot of people thougt he lost and people were questionin if miguel was the same fighter he was since the margarito incident and clottey just lost to miguel

[infamous larryx]

roy jones just tko'd lacy before fighting danny green, does that mean he wasn't shot?

morales was shot after the raheem beat down who did he ever beat??