Who Has The Better Resume?

[letsgobrady]

floyds best wins

1-corrales-former champ at 130 p4p top 5
2-mosley-wba champ p4p#3
3-hatton-linear lww champ,former wba ww champ top 5 p4p
4-oscar-wbc lmw champ
5-hernendez-#1 at 130 wbc champ
6-judah-former linear champ at ww
7-gatti-wbc lww champ
8-castillo-wbc lw champ
9-baldo-linear ww champ
10-jmm-linear lw champ-p4p#2

can some list mannys top 10 wins please....

i think their resumes are pretty even

carlos hernandez and jesus chavez should be up there to

[Toney616]

true.............................................. ...........................

Without his clinching what does Hatton have? No jab, no defense and way too left hand dominant. He also has a hitch in his left shoulder, so he has to pull it back to generate power i.e elite fighters can see it coming. When Pac started to throw his counter right hook Hatton was basically "naked" in the ring.

[letsgobrady]

floyds wins over genaro hernandez and jesus chavez are as good if not better than manny's win over marquez and barrera

[letsgobrady]

Because Barrera was better than Castillo, P4P.

i don't know if he was better when he got knocked out twice by a fighter that is not looked at as great as chico

[infamous larryx]

floyds wins over genaro hernandez and jesus chavez are as good if not better than manny's win over marquez and barrera

this is what people fail to realize..look at the top 10 wins listed for manny..they listed mab 2 times and put oscar larios on it..sad

[infamous larryx]

i have to ask how is mannys resume better than floyds??

sorry but mannys best wins are

barrera
jmm
cotto
hatton
oscar*

and thats about it....and oscars just on there cause manny jumped weight to beat him

floyds resume is better and has more prime fighters

i cant even list morales for manny cause he lost the first fight and rematched him after he went up in weight and lost to raheem then drained him back down to 130..sorry

[letsgobrady]

regardless of what YOU think, manny's win on hatton was up there because he faced him at his prime weight...

u said it urself in floyd's top wins - "hatton lineal lww champ"...

hatton was a powerhouse at jr welterweight...

u bring up undefeated, but dude was undefeated there..he ruled THAT division for years and years...pac just put it on him...

dude said "shell of hatton" lol...u box? cuz hatton was outboxing the boxer against malinaggi b4 pac...he looked great in that fight

who did ricky fight at jr ww?

what fight did u see that hatton outboxed paulie?hatton didn't out box anyone he would just land a hook everytime paulie fell into a semi clinch and pulled out of the clinch and paulie himself only threw 1 right hand and that 1 right hand seem to make hatton stumble andin his fight before that against lazcano it looked like ricky was gonna get dropped again

[letsgobrady]

this is what people fail to realize..look at the top 10 wins listed for manny..they listed mab 2 times and put oscar larios on it..sad

people only remeber recent history and what manny has done has been more recent than when floyd was doin his thing thats all it is and most pacfans are ******s too

[Toney616]

floyds wins over genaro hernandez and jesus chavez are as good if not better than manny's win over marquez and barrera

Both Barrera and Marquez are definite HOFers, who were still elite fighters when Pac faced them. Wasn't Hernandez at the end of his career and what has Jesus Chavez done?

[RimmyDelicious]

The poll speaks for itself, really. Floyd fans can argue until they are blue in the face but the facts speak for themselves no matter how you twist them.