Who Has The Better Resume?

[ummeed]

morales was shot after the raheem beat down who did he ever beat??

none, but that's because he fought pac right after that.

[letsgobrady]

Its been a while since ive seen that fight, so im going to have to watch it agin and post up my scorecard.

I never said it doesn't count, please don't start putting words in my mouth.

Barrera first ballot hofer, showed he still had a lot left in the tank by beating Eric and holding his own against jmm. I scored that fight for barrera

jmm hof as well, showed he had a lot left in the tank, by moving up and beating Casamajor and Diaz

Are you comparing those wins to
Barrera: Morales I, Morales II, Hamed
Jmm: Casamajor, Diaz, Barrera* (I thought he lost this)

Ricky shouldn't fight again after that brutal ko, as for Oscar he got koed by a sfw, he should retire

u ask me to name some of chavez wins so i gave u some
what did hamed do after losin to barerra? retire so if floyd doesn't get credit for genero than neither should barerra for beatin the prince which only leaves morales on his resume

[qwerty07]

margo or cotto???lol..yea right

This is the problem with you *****s, you overrate him you because THINK he would beat guys in fantasy fights.

You think he shouldn't have to fight cotto or marg or clottey or prime shane because he "would've" beaten them.

You think he shouldn't have to fight tszyu because he "would've" beaten him.

If he had beaten all this guys, no doubt his resume would be very good, but just because you think he COULD beat them doesn't make him better than his resume. and his resume says he hasn't beaten any of them.

[qwerty07]

This is kinda ignorant. Because you can nit pick at Pacquiao's best wins too.

MAB: Good win
EM x3: Lost one, won 2 against shot, old and drained morales
JMM x2: 1 loss, 1 win(disputable)
Hatton: If mayweather fought a **** version, pacquiao fought a worse version
Clottey: Doesn't punch back, gatekeeper, nobody
ODLH: If mayweather fought a **** version, pacquiao fought a drained **** version
Cotto: Drained and shot.

So what, he only had 1 legit win?

The difference is, most of my reasons were based on facts, while almost all your reasons are based on opinions. I'm not sure you know the difference between a fact and an opinion.

[letsgobrady]

that was my point. i was asking if roy wasn't shot just because he tko'd lacy. it was in response to larry's post saying mosley, dlh, and jmm weren't shot because they won their previous wins by KO.

did marquez,mosley and oscar beat what was conciderd overrated fighters?from what i remember everyone thought shane was gonna lose to margarito and i;m not sure if jmm was the favorite against cassamyor or diaz

[RimmyDelicious]

The poll speaks for itself.

[letsgobrady]

This is the problem with you *****s, you overrate him you because THINK he would beat guys in fantasy fights.

You think he shouldn't have to fight cotto or marg or clottey or prime shane because he "would've" beaten them.

You think he shouldn't have to fight tszyu because he "would've" beaten him.

If he had beaten all this guys, no doubt his resume would be very good, but just because you think he COULD beat them doesn't make him better than his resume. and his resume says he hasn't beaten any of them.

didn't manny turn down a fight with shane because shane was to much of a risk?

[infamous larryx]

The poll speaks for itself.

you nor any other poster have said why mannys resume is better

[qwerty07]

didn't manny turn down a fight with shane because shane was to much of a risk?

Yeah, according to ***** speculation. But I don't put much stock in that.

[letsgobrady]

You said I said,"it doesn't count"
Barrera near prime greater than past prime Hernadez

how is barrera so great when everyone he beat besides erik were in the same position genero was hamed stopped fighting and kelly took 2 years off came back got a couple bull**** wins then lost to bobby pacquiao