Who Has The Better Resume?

[letsgobrady]

roy jones just tko'd lacy before fighting danny green, does that mean he wasn't shot?

didn't lacy get stopped by taylor before fighting jones?was lacy not looked at as a shot overrated fighter?

[Gutz]

yep..cause floyd retired and said **** everyone..thats why manny won

Why.. He could have lost.. to Cotto or Marg... But we would have never know..


And he if won.. Then I would have voted Floyd to have the better resume..

[infamous larryx]

Why.. He could have lost.. to Cotto or Marg... But we would have never know..


And he if won.. Then I would have voted Floyd to have the better resume..

margo or cotto???lol..yea right

[letsgobrady]

What has Chavez done? Barerra (a little past prime) is a first ballot hofer, its a great win for pac. Hernadez was past prime and retired after that fight. Pac should of been given a 10-6 lead after the first round with jmm, which they didn't do.
Barrera+Marquez>hernadez+Chavez

it doesn't make a difference if 1 judge scored it wrong he could of fixed but he didn't so that just goes to show that he didn't think manny won it's kinda hard to see manny clearly winning more than 2 rounds of the 1st fight.
genero hernandez was 31 or 32 when he fought floyd and had not lost in about 3-4years and that was to oscar in a higher weight.
so genero doesn't count because he retired after floyd beat him up?i don't remember ricky or oscar fighting again after they lost to manny

3 chavez wins
Leavander Johnson
Emanuel Augustus
carlos gerena

and erik morales struggled to beat chavez 3 years after floyd beat him

[ummeed]

didn't lacy get stopped by taylor before fighting jones?was lacy not looked at as a shot overrated fighter?

that was my point. i was asking if roy wasn't shot just because he tko'd lacy. it was in response to larry's post saying mosley, dlh, and jmm weren't shot because they won their previous wins by KO.

[Toney616]

it doesn't make a difference if 1 judge scored it wrong he could of fixed but he didn't so that just goes to show that he didn't think manny won it's kinda hard to see manny clearly winning more than 2 rounds of the 1st fight.

Its been a while since ive seen that fight, so im going to have to watch it agin and post up my scorecard.

genero hernandez was 31 or 32 when he fought floyd and had not lost in about 3-4years and that was to oscar in a higher weight.
so genero doesn't count because he retired after floyd beat him up?i don't remember ricky or oscar fighting again after they lost to manny

I never said it doesn't count, please don't start putting words in my mouth.

Barrera first ballot hofer, showed he still had a lot left in the tank by beating Eric and holding his own against jmm. I scored that fight for barrera

jmm hof as well, showed he had a lot left in the tank, by moving up and beating Casamajor and Diaz

3 chavez wins
Leavander Johnson
Emanuel Augustus
carlos gerena

Are you comparing those wins to
Barrera: Morales I, Morales II, Hamed
Jmm: Casamajor, Diaz, Barrera* (I thought he lost this)

Ricky shouldn't fight again after that brutal ko, as for Oscar he got koed by a sfw, he should retire

[letsgobrady]

Why.. He could have lost.. to Cotto or Marg... But we would have never know..


And he if won.. Then I would have voted Floyd to have the better resume..

who the **** is margarito?margarito only has a name because of floyd mayweather.floyd also tried to get a fight with miguel at 140 but bob turned it down

[infamous larryx]

that was my point. i was asking if roy wasn't shot just because he tko'd lacy. it was in response to larry's post saying mosley, dlh, and jmm weren't shot because they won their previous wins by KO.

oscar was the wbc champ at 154
jmm was the linear and unified lw champ and p4p#2
mosley was p4p#3 and whe wba champ



morales was-shot and just got embarrased by raheem and forced back to 130 where he was drained..hell roach even put that weight penalty bull**** in the contract

[letsgobrady]

he was at the end of his career and retired after that fight, you cannot compare that win to pacs win over barrera

u saaid this right?

[Toney616]

u saaid this right?

You said I said,"it doesn't count"
Barrera near prime greater than past prime Hernadez