Is Shane Mosley an ATG?

[Miburo]

He is an all time great if not for anything but the type of work he put in at 135 - 140

While his performances were impressive, his level of opposition wasn't. Had he stayed in those weight ranges and fought more credible people, who knows. Mayweather would have beaten him in those same years.

[FightMoney]

While his performances were impressive, his level of opposition wasn't. Had he stayed in those weight ranges and fought more credible people, who knows. Mayweather would have beaten him in those same years.

Mayweather is an ATG...no shame in losing to another ATG

[Obama]

Of course he is.

[MARKBNLV]

Of course he is.

How is that explain.

[Miburo]

How is that explain.

Don't bother, 90% of the comments were of this sort, as if one can be disdainfully dismissive of debate regarding what in reality is a highly questionable claim.

[check hook]

if managed the mayweather way yea he could have. fighting smaller and older big name fighters while avoiding winky and forrest would have done his career wonders. he screwed up big time.

yeah..cause a career 130 pounder should need to go to 154 and prove himself against Winky Wright.........eat a **** ****

[Miburo]

yeah..cause a career 130 pounder should need to go to 154 and prove himself against Winky Wright.........eat a **** ****

Let's be accurate here - Mosley only fought a handful of fights at 135 even, shrinking down from around the 140 limit he fought the majority of his early career at.

[Ray*]

This is what i dont get about people going on and on about ATG!!! So Mosley is an ATG? HOF yes but an ATG? **** that, I havent seen an ATG in the last 15 years in boxing.

[tyger]

He was a great fighter with a great career, but I don't think he's an ATG.

[Roy Hobbs]

No on the atg status. shane is a great fighter, definitely hall of fame but he's below atg level in my opinion.