Would you bash Floyd if he decided to fight Martinez for the belts at a 158 catch?

[infamous larryx]

160 or no titles..if he wants to come in under 160 fine..but dont change the rules of a weight limit for the other fighter...middleweight is 155-160..not 155-158

[Dick Buffman]

WW is 140.1-147. Nothing wrong with Pac-Cotto.

MW is 154.1-160. Nothing wrong with Floyd-Martinez under the same circumstances.

Cotto WASN'T ALLOWED TO WEIGH 47'!

[mellow_mood]

160 or no titles....

[Doctor_Tenma]

WW is 140.1-147. Nothing wrong with Pac-Cotto.

MW is 154.1-160. Nothing wrong with Floyd-Martinez under the same circumstances.

There is alot wrong with that.

[jrosales13]

Martinez didn't need a catweight to take Kelly's belts so I don't see the reason why May should get a free pass for demanding a catchweight, 160 lbs or bust.

Martinez is a big JMW who has fought at MW before. Floyd is a WW who can still easily make WW and has never fought at MW before big difference.

[Dick Buffman]

I don't understand you people that are voting yes.

Why the **** are we making exceptions for select fighters? Lets just do away w/ the damn weight classes altogether if you're gonna allow a select few to come in at their own weight class.


160 or no titles mother****ers.

[El 7 Mares V.2]

Martinez is a big Welterweight that comfortably fights at his right weight which is JMW. Stop smearing crap.

[David_TheMan]

I don't see why Floyd and Martinez couldn't fight at 154 for both of Martinez's titles.

[MurderDeathKill]

Cotto WASN'T ALLOWED TO WEIGH 47'!

I know. He was allowed to weigh 145, which is within the WW limit.

There is alot wrong with that.

No there isn't. If both guys agree, then it's a fight. Period.

[Doctor_Tenma]

No problem with that... Martinez would come in at around 158 regardless of the catchweight.

I believe he was 158-159lbs for the Williams fight at MW.

It's the thought of restricting the champion from coming in at the limit of the division he campaigns at. I see alot wrong with that.