Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[tibbar]

pacquiao doesnt care about that P4P title, why should we??? for all i care BS can shove the title up Floyds Punk azz/

[jrosales13]

and also j-ro, i would liek to add that manny never even beat the man to become #1, he got it by default.

Cotto was a good win, but it was at a catchweight and clottey wasn't really a top 5 ww. I would rank berto, mosley, cotto, floyd, and pacquiao above him.

The ranking is right and most people knew who the real #1 was before the fight saturday! Just my opinion.

But, that is not how it works either. Going by that logic means Floyd got it by default also. He did not beat the #1 guy either.

Again you don't have to beat the #1 guy to be the #1 P4P.

That is not how this list works.

[spider8124]

clif****edbyfloyd

maybe ****ingfloyd ****ed your ass that's why you ranked him number 1 by beating an old****ing boxer. you're just a pac hater that is why?????????????

[znarfv_y2k8]

Ring Magazine has it's rating panel:

The Ring Rating Panel
Mark Abrams
Carlos Arias
Eric Armit
Bill Calogero
Nick Charles
Brian Doogan
Coyote Duran
J. Michael Falgoust
Steve Farhood
Doug Fischer
Margaret Goodman, M.D.
Lee Groves
Jack Hirsch
Michael Hirsley
Keith Idec
Carlos Irusta
Ted Lerner
Marc Lichtenfeld
Jessi Losado
Scott Mallon
Rich Marotta
David Mayo
Barry McGuigan
Marty Mulcahey
Bernard Osuna
Vittorio Parisi
Matt Richardson
Cliff Rold
Michael Rosenthal
Rick Scharmberg
Don Steinberg
Joe Tessitore
Paul Upham
Claude Vesque
Calvin Watkins
John Whistler
Phil Woolever
Kurt Wolfheimer 15rounds.com
Orange County Register
British Boxing Yearbook
thedailysports.com
Showtime
London Sunday Times
doghouseboxing.com
USA Today
Showtime
ringtv.com
secondsout.com
CompuBox
Boxing News
Chicago Tribune
Herald News of New Jersey
El Grafico
The Ring
Through The Ropes
Telemundo
asianboxingnews.com
FSN-TV, KFI/KLAC Radio
Grand Rapids Press
ITV
maxboxing.com
Telefutura
nonsoloboxe.it
*********.com
boxingscene.com
ringtv.com
*********.com
The Philadelphia Inquirer
ESPN
Fist/FSN-TV
Wikipedia Editor
Dallas Morning News
San Antonio Express News
Boxing Digest
*********.com

Yahoo Boxing has it's voting panel:

Voting panel: Raul Alzaga, Primera Hora; Steve Cofield, Yahoo! Sports; Dave Cokin, ESPN Radio 1100, Las Vegas; Andrew Eisele, About.com; Doug Fischer, Ring; Scott Fyfe, Sunday Post, Scotland; Thomas Gerbasi, Boxingscene.com; Carlos Gonzalez, Primera Hora; Lee Groves, BoxingScene.com; Thomas Hauser, Seconds Out.com; Keith Idec, Herald News, New Jersey; Kevin Iole, Yahoo! Sports; Max Kellerman, HBO; Scott Mallon, Asian Boxing News; Chris Mannix, Sports Illustrated; Rich Marotta, Fox Sports; David Mayo, Grand Rapids Press; Franklin McNeil, ESPN; Gunnar Meinhardt, Die Welt; Robert Morales, Los Angeles Daily News; Marty Mulcahey, MaxBoxing.com; Kieran Mulvaney, Reuters; Brett Okamoto, Las Vegas Sun; Santos Perez, Miami Herald; Martin Rogers, Yahoo! Sports; Lem Satterfield, Fanhouse.com; Tim Smith, New York Daily News; T.K. Stewart, Boxingscene.com; John Whisler, San Antonio Express-News; George Willis, New York Post.

I don't know about BoxingScene's if Cliff Rold acts alone:

[crold1]

Ring Magazine has it's rating panel:

The Ring Rating Panel
Mark Abrams
Carlos Arias
Eric Armit
Bill Calogero
Nick Charles
Brian Doogan
Coyote Duran
J. Michael Falgoust
Steve Farhood
Doug Fischer
Margaret Goodman, M.D.
Lee Groves
Jack Hirsch
Michael Hirsley
Keith Idec
Carlos Irusta
Ted Lerner
Marc Lichtenfeld
Jessi Losado
Scott Mallon
Rich Marotta
David Mayo
Barry McGuigan
Marty Mulcahey
Bernard Osuna
Vittorio Parisi
Matt Richardson
Cliff Rold
Michael Rosenthal
Rick Scharmberg
Don Steinberg
Joe Tessitore
Paul Upham
Claude Vesque
Calvin Watkins
John Whistler
Phil Woolever
Kurt Wolfheimer 15rounds.com
Orange County Register
British Boxing Yearbook
thedailysports.com
Showtime
London Sunday Times
doghouseboxing.com
USA Today
Showtime
ringtv.com
secondsout.com
CompuBox
Boxing News
Chicago Tribune
Herald News of New Jersey
El Grafico
The Ring
Through The Ropes
Telemundo
asianboxingnews.com
FSN-TV, KFI/KLAC Radio
Grand Rapids Press
ITV
maxboxing.com
Telefutura
nonsoloboxe.it
*********.com
boxingscene.com
ringtv.com
*********.com
The Philadelphia Inquirer
ESPN
Fist/FSN-TV
Wikipedia Editor
Dallas Morning News
San Antonio Express News
Boxing Digest
*********.com

Yahoo Boxing has it's voting panel:

Voting panel: Raul Alzaga, Primera Hora; Steve Cofield, Yahoo! Sports; Dave Cokin, ESPN Radio 1100, Las Vegas; Andrew Eisele, About.com; Doug Fischer, Ring; Scott Fyfe, Sunday Post, Scotland; Thomas Gerbasi, Boxingscene.com; Carlos Gonzalez, Primera Hora; Lee Groves, BoxingScene.com; Thomas Hauser, Seconds Out.com; Keith Idec, Herald News, New Jersey; Kevin Iole, Yahoo! Sports; Max Kellerman, HBO; Scott Mallon, Asian Boxing News; Chris Mannix, Sports Illustrated; Rich Marotta, Fox Sports; David Mayo, Grand Rapids Press; Franklin McNeil, ESPN; Gunnar Meinhardt, Die Welt; Robert Morales, Los Angeles Daily News; Marty Mulcahey, MaxBoxing.com; Kieran Mulvaney, Reuters; Brett Okamoto, Las Vegas Sun; Santos Perez, Miami Herald; Martin Rogers, Yahoo! Sports; Lem Satterfield, Fanhouse.com; Tim Smith, New York Daily News; T.K. Stewart, Boxingscene.com; John Whisler, San Antonio Express-News; George Willis, New York Post.

I don't know about BoxingScene's if Cliff Rold acts alone:

Ring's P4P ratings are not directly influenced by the panel, though panelists I'm sure weigh in. That's purely their east coast editorial staff who determines their P4P. The advisors are there to comment on the division ratings.

[crold1]

maybe ****ingfloyd ****ed your ass that's why you ranked him number 1 by beating an old****ing boxer. you're just a pac hater that is why?????????????

LOL...I was one of the first writers to put Pac #1 back when he beat Morales the second time. My rationale for this move is explained. Sorry you don't like it but get a grip kid.