Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[EL ANIMAL]

im a floyd fan but its either a tie for number one or pac. To be number one you have to beat number one...

i agree as well!!! I think it should be atleast a draw!!!!
I mean pac ko'd the last man that beat shane!!! (b4 floyd)
i say a draw atleast!!!!!
Also pac beat hatton and dela-hoya way worst then floyd did.

A draw for numero uno !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
They both are number 1 right now!!!!!!!!

[BritishBoxing92]

Until Pacquiao loses he hold the top spot.

i second that

[nj_evoixgsr]

shane was bigger and 5 years isnt much older 33/38 is not much older. Knock outs dont make u a great boxer either man. Though pac is great styles make fights how many times do i have to yell that where are the real boxing fans at???????? Skills are extraordinary

that's a funny statement 5 years is nothing but 2lbs less than welterweight limit and every busted pac's chops? are you serious?

it's not about who cares who's at top of "mythical" p4p list but how the fck do you go from beating #3 and the way it came out to giving #2 #1 for beating #3? doesn't make much sense. I think the people who changed that were floyd fans or just waiting for something to give them a little bit more hmph or pad on his resume to jump him up.

sorry but that was a horrible shane he faced and he still didn't knock him out. i would hope he would go on offense cause shane obviously didn't have an offense of his own to dish out to make pbf go into defensive mode.

i think overrated hatton did a much better job.


BTW, THE TRUE P4P LIST STILL HAS PAC #1 AS OF MAY 4! B*tches.

[EL ANIMAL]

no way floyd should be number 1 pacs been fighting all the time for years mayweathers had two fights since 07 and then had one fight in a year pacs fought some of the same guys and pacs looked way beter doin it until they meeet an mayweather wins hes behin in my eyes

nuff said!!!! I'm a mayweather fan actually of both but u can dampen a mans accomplishments just yet!!!!!!
I would atleast say a draw!!!!!

[jrosales13]

Im a floyd fan but its either a tie for number one or Pac. To be number one you have to beat number one...

Couldn't agree more myself. Shouldn't the saying "to be the man, you have to beat the man" apply in this case?

No it does not work that way for P4P.

Even though I still have Pac at 1. He does not have to lose to put Floyd at #1. I have no problem with either guy at the top spot right now.

[SceneSpectator!]

B-Scene simply carried by Floyd's win euphoria! I couldn't agree to this because while Floyd wins to Shane as #1 or #2 Welter, he was rocked by Shane in Round #2 that he almost go. Pac on the other hand fought 2 of the top 5 welters and handled them well comfortably and without blemished. While both in perfect fights on their recent fights, Floyd is a boring counter-punching technician hence Pac is an exciting offensive tactician!

[jtiger78]

that's a funny statement 5 years is nothing but 2lbs less than welterweight limit and every busted pac's chops? Are you serious?

It's not about who cares who's at top of "mythical" p4p list but how the fck do you go from beating #3 and the way it came out to giving #2 #1 for beating #3? Doesn't make much sense. I think the people who changed that were floyd fans or just waiting for something to give them a little bit more hmph or pad on his resume to jump him up.

Sorry but that was a horrible shane he faced and he still didn't knock him out. I would hope he would go on offense cause shane obviously didn't have an offense of his own to dish out to make pbf go into defensive mode.

I think overrated hatton did a much better job.


Btw, the true p4p list still has pac #1 as of may 4! B*tches.

shane just didnt know what to do with the monster technician in front of him! U cant say just because he looked bad it was a terrible shane he had a puzzle in front of him that he simply could not solve and that takes your heart will and determination. He didnt have to knock him out he took his spirit and out boxed him thats better than a knock out sometimes but it all depends on what kind of boxing fan u r me myself loved what i saw saturday without the knock out. Manny winning a 147 at 145 is bull**** no matter how u cut it but whatever the man is a beast we just need to see him vs floyd to settle it all i dont care about a list because just like boxingscene has a list you can have one so why dont u type it up and put it on here if u care that much! And dont act like pac hasnt been facing guys who play into his fighting style its simple if ur flatfooted and stand in front of pac ur going down! He will destroy you and thats what he has faced in his last 3 or 4 fights i think everyone has caught on man its obvious he struggles with movement and counterpunching so once i see him fight and dominate someone of floyds skill or a boxer who moves ill give him the #1 respect u feel he deserves!

[jtiger78]

b-scene simply carried by floyd's win euphoria! I couldn't agree to this because while floyd wins to shane as #1 or #2 welter, he was rocked by shane in round #2 that he almost go. Pac on the other hand fought 2 of the top 5 welters and handled them well comfortably and without blemished. While both in perfect fights on their recent fights, floyd is a boring counter-punching technician hence pac is an exciting offensive tactician!

how is it without blemish when his face is busted up in both of his last 2 fights? Being more exciting has nothing to do with reality also

[DuttyAlacrity]

i still think Pac deserves #1 but i won't complain that floyd is now #1. they are so close to eachother that you could argue either way!

I can digg it

[cortdawg25]

no it does not work that way for p4p.

Even though i still have pac at 1. He does not have to lose to put floyd at #1. I have no problem with either guy at the top spot right now.

and also j-ro, i would liek to add that manny never even beat the man to become #1, he got it by default.

Cotto was a good win, but it was at a catchweight and clottey wasn't really a top 5 ww. I would rank berto, mosley, cotto, floyd, and pacquiao above him.

The ranking is right and most people knew who the real #1 was before the fight saturday! Just my opinion.