Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[Eric Holder]

good list...

[blacksocks]

I guess we're so used to Pac knocking out and dominating guys bigger than him that it becomes ordinary. Now here comes Floyd who returns to fight a smaller guy and a much older one without even knocking them out and people see it as something special and extraordinary.

Cotto beats Mosley and no doubt Clottey beats Marquez. That's 2-0 in favor of Pac's recent opponents against Floyd's.

[jtiger78]

ITS ALL OPINION ANYWAY (EVERYONE HAS THEIR OPINION) SO WHO CARES? GET UR PANTIES OUT OF A BUNCH PAC FANS THE WORLD WILL NOT END BECAUSE OF AN OPINION TAKE A CHILL PILL AND GO DRINK OR SOMETHING U GUYS ACT LIKE PAC IS THE MOST HIGH HIMSELF

[jtiger78]

i guess we're so used to pac knocking out and dominating guys bigger than him that it becomes ordinary. Now here comes floyd who returns to fight a smaller guy and a much older one without even knocking them out and people see it as something special and extraordinary.

Cotto beats mosley and no doubt clottey beats marquez. That's 2-0 in favor of pac's recent opponents against floyd's.

shane was bigger and 5 years isnt much older 33/38 is not much older. Knock outs dont make u a great boxer either man. Though pac is great styles make fights how many times do i have to yell that where are the real boxing fans at???????? Skills are extraordinary

[Makunochi Ippo]

The P4P king has 5 decision wins in the last 6 fights in the last 4 years. The #2 ranked has 2 decision wins in the last 6 fights in the last 2 years. The P4P king deserves the top spot. Seriously.. Not.

Anyway hopefully they meet next to settle it once and for all.

[iRealChamp]

Im a floyd fan but its either a tie for number one or Pac. To be number one you have to beat number one...

[glennster]

Boxing knowledge and experience
DR. ORGYY < Boxing Scene

Boxing Scene < Ring

[glennster]

Im a floyd fan but its either a tie for number one or Pac. To be number one you have to beat number one...

Couldn't agree more myself. Shouldn't the saying "to be the man, you have to beat the man" apply in this case?

[DeLaHoya1fan]

Boxing Scene < Ring

since you value the Ring so much, you do know by their standards Floyd should be #1 right?

explained it here

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?p=8253809#post8253809

boxing scene got it right.

[EL ANIMAL]

until pacquiao loses he hold the top spot.

i agree!!!