Better win - Pac v Cotto, or Floyd vs Shane?

[Porter's Dad]

I was going with the cotto win until i realise the fight was at 145...So i would call it a draw, I knew both would win but i was taken over by both Pac and Mayweather's performance.

I said at the time that making the fight at a catch-weight would diminish the significance of a win. I mean, all for the sake of 2 pounds. So while I personally do not believe that Miguel was affected by the weight, it is hard to rebut people who have an issue with it. Team Pacquaio would have known this, although I'm guessing they frankly don't give a ****.

[ThePunchingBag]

I actually consider Pac's win over Clottey more impressive.

When was the last time Clottey got dominated in the way that he did against Pacquiao?

When was the last time Mosley got dominated? Forrest? Winky?

[elfag]

mosley was as good as he could have been given his age. He would have defeated the Cotto and clottey that pac fought.

[elfag]

I actually consider Pac's win over Clottey more impressive.

When was the last time Clottey got dominated in the way that he did against Pacquiao?

When was the last time Mosley got dominated? Forrest? Winky?

uh maybe that has something to do with clottey not having fought forrest or winky

[Kobe B Bryant]

mosley was as good as he could have been given his age. He would have defeated the Cotto and clottey that pac fought.

really?

the mosley from last night who was tired after 4 rounds?



anyways.

[boxasmash]

Cotto, Cotto beat Mosley himself, Pac just beat Cotto's ass down. Mosley looked old and slow.

[FloydTBE]

Floyd-Mosley wasnt at 145lbs, it was at the full welterwight limit. 50/50 pickem before the first bell.

FLoyd win for sure

[barafranca]

Cotto beat Shane. nuff said

[fugu]

Mosley but not by that much.

People are saying Mosley is shot, but seriously, Mayweather always make people look very bad.

Cotto at 147 would have been equal to a Mosley win in my books.

[fugu]

Cotto beat Shane. nuff said

Different Cotto, possibly different shane.