Better win - Pac v Cotto, or Floyd vs Shane?

[Kobe B Bryant]

well Pacquiao has pretty much admitted he was on steroids, whereas we know for a fact Floyd and Shane weren't. Gotta go with Floyd's win.

bull****!

you a motherfucking liar!



pacquiao doesn't do steroids. he blood dopes.

[Porter's Dad]

I think it really is close.

I think it really is debatable...

Yeah man, it has flummoxed me. And I don't think once the glow of Floyd's win, which is still burning bright in our mind, dims that it'll make the choice any easier.

Floyd's was a stunning execution of technique, skill and smarts, while Pac's was a tour-de-force of explosiveness, dynamicism and relentlessness. (Both, of course, had some of all those factors)

[Kobe B Bryant]

............No.

...............Yes.

[Kobe B Bryant]

anyways why we talking about floyd , manny , miguel and shane?

they're the past.

let's talk about the future.



saul alvarez.

[And Still]

I wouldve picked a 2009/10 Mosley to stop that Post-Marg Cotto at 145.

Floyd gets my vote.

Shane was coming off a dominant win over margarito. Cotto was coming of a beating tajen in a loss, and a iffy showing vs Clottey.

Shane didn't just get tired after six minutes. Dude was running 5 miles day and sparring . The problem is that he couldn't relax. His anxiety got the best of him. Floyd got into his head.

[Shadow boxer 3]

cotto had been beating down by plaster and clottey gav him all he could handle. dont get me wrong its a great win for pac but cotto had some damage on him plus the fight was at 145. im going with floyd-mosley

[warp1432]

Don't get me wrong though, Pacquiao's win over Cotto is pretty good. I think I might be the only person on this board, who values the Hatton win for both Pacquiao and Mayweather too.

[Boxingholic]

Cotto win of course

[Blubba]

Cotto win easily.

got to put things in perspective in how bad Mosley was when a blown up super feather like Marquez looked alot more competitive compared to a full welter like Mosley.

[Guest]

Don't get me wrong though, Pacquiao's win over Cotto is pretty good. I think I might be the only person on this board, who values the Hatton win for both Pacquiao and Mayweather too.

I rate the Hatton win for Mayweather very highly.

Hatton was undefeated when Floyd took that scalp.

He was the man who retired Kostya Tszyu.

It's easy to see Hatton's flaws in hindsight but he was an undefeated killer when Floyd beat him.

Not so much with Pac...