Better win - Pac v Cotto, or Floyd vs Shane?

[Kobe B Bryant]

cotto had been beating down by plaster and clottey gav him all he could handle. dont get me wrong its a great win for pac but cotto had some damage on him plus the fight was at 145. im going with floyd-mosley

man , mosley had taken the same amount of beating cotto accumulated in the marg fight like 7 years ago.

[Ray*]

I was going with the cotto win until i realise the fight was at 145...So i would call it a draw, I knew both would win but i was taken over by both Pac and Mayweather's performance.

[Blubba]

cotto had been beating down by plaster and clottey gav him all he could handle. dont get me wrong its a great win for pac but cotto had some damage on him plus the fight was at 145. im going with floyd-mosley

and Mosley is almost 39 and cant even stop himself from shaking his own arse off. lol!

[Kobe B Bryant]

I rate the Hatton win for Mayweather very highly.

Hatton was undefeated when Floyd took that scalp.

He was the man who retired Kostya Tszyu.

It's easy to see Hatton's flaws in hindsight but he was an undefeated killer when Floyd beat him.

Not so much with Pac...

thank god , i couldn't get a hold of you yesterday , juwan.

i was thinking of putting a bill or two on sugar.

[HitmanHattonAY]

I think Mayweather gets my vote, Cotto had to come down to 145 and he just edged a slip decision win over Clottey. Where as Mosley had KO'd Margarito in a fight most boxing analyst were saying that it was the best performance of his carrer.

Mayweather gets my vote

[Pacquiao'd]

Remember that Pac was moving up in weight for his fight with Cotto.

I think Pac's win over Cotto is better because it was his first real welterweight challenge. (zombie Oscar doesn't count)

Mosley did look a bit shot/overtrained to be honest.

you fail, pac had already fought oscar at 147 so the moving up in weight excuse wont fly...try again

[-Spinal-]

Lol I see Tua got a new disguise.

I won't tell on you broski.

[Kobe B Bryant]

Lol I see Tua got a new disguise.

I won't tell on you broski.

nicca , you bouts to get me banned again!



who's tua?

[gongin]

shane didnt weight 145..floyd-shane=real ww fight..not some catchweight bull****

Did floyd destroyed shane like the way pac did to cotto?Old shane mosley compare to cotto in his primes...yo *****h could knockout a chicken legs old mosleys..You should back up yo boy ..that would be your only "american black hope" lol spot on..

[warp1432]

I rate the Hatton win for Mayweather very highly.

Hatton was undefeated when Floyd took that scalp.

He was the man who retired Kostya Tszyu.

It's easy to see Hatton's flaws in hindsight but he was an undefeated killer when Floyd beat him.

Not so much with Pac...

The way Pac wiped him out was so impressive.