Better win - Pac v Cotto, or Floyd vs Shane?

[warp1432]

...........No

Clottey too. Actually all of those are wrong

[Porter's Dad]

Cotto won every round of the Margarito fight until the plaster hardened. Now he's damaged goods?

How is he not damaged goods? Those first 6 rounds of that first were the last time we will see a prime Miguel. That, and the Clottey fight were rough, rough fights, they took something out of Cotto mentally and physically. There's no disgrace in admitting that, I'm a huge Miguel fan.

[jrosales13]

I think it really is close.

I think it really is debatable...

[jrosales13]

Clottey too. Actually all of those are wrong

I think Shane would beat him but I think it would be close. I think Clottey style could give Shane fits.

I think Shane would beat Cotto too but again I think it won't be dominant victory.

Mainly what I am saying is that I wouldn't be surprise if Cotto or Clottey beat Shane.

However, Hatton zero chance. I would be shocked if Hatton beat him.

[Porter's Dad]

I have to say the Cotto win, close though.

Very close indeed, I genuinely cannot separate the two. Pac's win against Cotto has become ridiculously underrated, primarily because Team Mayweather started peddling the PED-stuff straight after, and the merits of the win became drowned out, and the side-show took over.

[johncods]

Well cotto already beat a 2 year younger Shane mosley and would still beat him now.

[Doctor_Tenma]

Mayweather faught Mosley at 147.

[Kobe B Bryant]

Mosley did look a bit shot/overtrained to be honest.

39 yrs. old.

in 2 training camps for a total of 4 months in the last 6 months.

16 month layoff.

[DiegoFuego]

well Pacquiao has pretty much admitted he was on steroids, whereas we know for a fact Floyd and Shane weren't. Gotta go with Floyd's win.

[-Spinal-]

cotto win.



i think cotto , hatton , clottey could have beat the mosley that showed up last night.

............No.