If floyd beats shane, is it a better win than manny's win against barrera?

[MaD RoBoT]

if you have to ask then you are already wrong. That was not even 75% of what cotto was after margacheato did what he did.

so Cotto pre-Marg was what, less than that after he was wobbled by both Torres & Chop-Chop?

[baracuda]

if you have to ask then you are already wrong. That was not even 75% of what cotto was after margacheato did what he did.

leave the mexican pride out of it then you could be sensible...........

[check hook]

Has MAB ever been better than Mosley at any stage of their respective careers.............????

the answer is no.


Mosley is getting discredited here on the daily.........it's some repugnant ****....the only blight SSM has against his name is PED use......

[Khalid X]

You got to be kidding me. Barrerra is way higher on the ATG list than Mosley. Not only does he have a better resume, he was a one of the greatest runs the FW division has ever seen. No way in hell does a win over Mosley equate or even surpass Manny's win over Barrera.

Again, I know this is a joke and all, so I kinda feel bad even replying to this..lol

[Khalid X]

barrera was no where near his prime when he fought pac-man, what are you talking about? How long you been a fan of the sweet science? My guess, not very long.......

LOL...

Barrera had just beaten Morales, Hamed, Sanchez, Kelly, Tapia, Salud, and was straight up destroying the FW division. Then Pac crushed him.

So it's damn near comical for you to say he wasn't in his prime, esp. when you considered after the Pac lost he went on the beat Morales, Ayala, Robbie Peden and Rocky Jaurez twice.

[TBear]

Barrera is a few years younger than Shane lol

[BawK]

Has MAB ever been better than Mosley at any stage of their respective careers.............????

the answer is no.


Mosley is getting discredited here on the daily.........it's some repugnant ****....the only blight SSM has against his name is PED use......

not putting down Shane but MAB has better resume

[NesNY]

in terms of each fighter's opposition at the time of the match.....it's arguable.

Mosley is May's biggest challenge to this point in his career...in the same way MAB was Pac's biggest challenge at that point.

Pac just happened to pummel his way through his toughest challenge, and nobody expects Mayweather to do that.
Can May outpoint Mosley, keep him off balance and MAKE him look every single day as old as he is?

Absolutely. And if he does, then yes - this win would be just as impressive as Pac over MAB.

[check hook]

not putting down Shane but MAB has better resume

not sure about that....


- wright (twice)
- forrest (twice)
- cotto
- margarito
- ODLH (twice)
- Collazo
- Mayorga
- Vargas

and now FMJ. How is MAB resume that much better than Shanes??

[pasawayako]

if floyd can do to shane what pac did to barrera in their 1st fight i'll consider floyd's win better.

I expect floyd to ko an old and past prime mosley. He doesn't have a shot against floyd.