If floyd beats shane, is it a better win than manny's win against barrera?

[Rolling Stone]

Shane >>> Barrera

[Ryannn]

LOL


Barrera

6 fights prior

Streak of impressive performances againts former champions in

Jesus Salud
Johny Tapia
Kevin Kelley
Erik Morales
Nazeem Hamed
Enrique Sanchez

Then went on another impressive run after the loss to Pacquiao
6 fights after

Paulie Ayala
Erik Morales
Fana
Robbie Peden
Rocky Juarez X2


Mosley


6 fights prior
Fernando Vargas X 2 - Well self explanatory to avoid the downplaying
Luis Collaso - Impressive
Miguel Cotto - LOST
Ricardo Mayorga - The KO saved shane but wasnt as impressive compared to the collazo fight
Antonio Margarito - Very Impressive



Its not even debatable at this point in time. Shane was a great fighter but not this version. This Version is not consistent. Shane needs another good run just to match what Barrera has done.

exactly.

this wasn't even supposed to be a serious thread.

[Ryannn]

Shane >>> Barrera

no.............

[Bong Bong]

That's how good Floyd is, a former Super Featherweight wins over Sugar Shane Mosley, #1 WW, is not much. A Pacquiao win over Sugar Shane Mosley...Pacquiao can retire with that win and didn't even need Barrera, Marquez or Morales. A win over Mosley is more impressive than a win over those 3 put together(for Pacquiao). But for Mayweather he needs to fight Mosley, Williams, Martinez, Ward, Dawson, Adamek, Wlad.

Easily one of the most ridiculous post Ive read in many years.

[Tamis!]

LOL look at the haters!

People even said at length that all Pac's fights was with fighters who are shot

Well not the first time he fought Barrera

[Ryannn]

LOL look at the haters!

People even said at length that all Pac's fights was with fighters who are shot

Well not the first time he fought Barrera

morales 1 and 2 wasn't shot.

jmm wasn't shot.

oscar was about as shot when he fought floyd.

cotto looked good as he ever did.

he fought hatton at his best weight.

mab, in no way shape or form is shot when they fought. even the second time.

[Tamis!]

morales 1 and 2 wasn't shot.

jmm wasn't shot.

oscar was about as shot when he fought floyd.

cotto looked good as he ever did.

he fought hatton at his best weight.

mab, in no way shape or form is shot when they fought. even the second time.

No matter how you lay it down to these guys, haters will say otherwise.

But that one fight that a young Pac blew a prime Barrera to smithereens squashes all doubt.

[guru]

No, Barrera was in his prime. Plus Pacquiao was the underdog.

This, pac pulled a major upset here. floyd beating shane is something that most of are expecting. the only way floyd MIGHT could possibly out do what pac did to MAB is if he brutally KO's shane.

[Tamis!]

This, pac pulled a major upset here. floyd beating shane is something that most of are expecting. the only way floyd MIGHT could possibly out do what pac did to MAB is if he brutally KO's shane.

Yeah!

I mean I like Shane, and this fight with Floyd's the toughest so far in the latter's career. Heck even uncle Roger and Sr. are on their toes.

So I don't see it compared to how Pacquiao beat Barrera in San Antonio, where NO ONE except the hardcore Pacfans, expected Manny to beat MAB. Prolly a shot at the moon chance but not even close at the odds on favorite scheme.

[STRUGG]

mayweather credit for beating shane....if by potshot....2/10...