If floyd beats shane, is it a better win than manny's win against barrera?

[Boxingholic]

Please Stop making grandpa Mosley, a super grandpa. Everyone know he is passed his prime, for heavens sake Shane is almost 40 YEARS OLD !!!

[daggum]

Mosley had some decent wins vs Vargas, Marg, Mayorga who came in at 170 or something huge + a close fight with pre tko loss Cotto, in recent times. I don't rate the Clottey win very highly at all but then again Mayorga/Vargas ain't the best wins ever either. Dela Hoya win was a joke and should not be mentioned though

well i dont rate welterweight hatton, welterewight marquez, baldomir, or judah very highly in fact no one does so i'm wondering how the hell mayweather is ranked so high and p4p #2? still living off those castillo and corrales wins i think. or was it gatti the win that propelled him to number 1.

[Roy Hobbs]

barrera was in his prime? Are you ****in ******? That's a joke right?

barrera was no where near his prime when he fought pac-man, what are you talking about? How long you been a fan of the sweet science? My guess, not very long.......

mab vs pacman 1, barerra was consensus p4p 3#. He was only 29 years old & had 8 wins in a row vs morales (morales first loss), johnny tapia, & naseem hamed before losing to manny. After he lost to many he won 6 fights in a row beating again morales to win the trilogy, robbie peden, paulie ayala, & 2 wins vs a young & up & coming rocky juarez. His next loss after getting beat by manny came way against another p4p top 10 elite juan manuel marquez in which he knocked marquez down.

That was a great win for pacquiao. Barerra was still prime. He might not have been undefeated super prime, but he certainly was still in his prime when pacquiao beat him. That beating he got from manny certainly nudged him just past prime.

[Ryannn]

mosley's win over margarito is so overrated its not even funny.

[TBear]

it would 'nt even be a betterr win than pac's W vs cotto..........

True.............

[Ryannn]

mab vs pacman 1, barerra was consensus p4p 3#. He was only 29 years old & had 8 wins in a row vs morales (morales first loss), johnny tapia, & naseem hamed before losing to manny. After he lost to many he won 6 fights in a row beating again morales to win the trilogy, robbie peden, paulie ayala, & 2 wins vs a young & up & coming rocky juarez. His next loss after getting beat by manny came way against another p4p top 10 elite juan manuel marquez in which he knocked marquez down.

That was a great win for pacquiao. Barerra was still prime. He might not have been undefeated super prime, but he certainly was still in his prime when pacquiao beat him. That beating he got from manny certainly nudged him just past prime.

yet some people say barrera was shot when manny fought, and mosley is super prime.

and people complain about pacquiao fans.

[BoxerDood]

True.............

I don't know...I think Shane would KO the Cotto that Pacquiao fought. I'd even pick Shane over a prime Cotto if they fought a rematch immediately. Let's not forget that a puddle of water saved Cotto from getting KTFO. That pissed me off more than when the ref saved Hatton from Lazcano...

[Gutz]

I don't know...I think Shane would KO the Cotto that Pacquiao fought.

Why do you think that??? Pac fought the same Cotto that beat Shane..


Cotto could still beat Mosley..

[pelonxsoldier28]

mab vs pacman 1, barerra was consensus p4p 3#. He was only 29 years old & had 8 wins in a row vs morales (morales first loss), johnny tapia, & naseem hamed before losing to manny. After he lost to many he won 6 fights in a row beating again morales to win the trilogy, robbie peden, paulie ayala, & 2 wins vs a young & up & coming rocky juarez. His next loss after getting beat by manny came way against another p4p top 10 elite juan manuel marquez in which he knocked marquez down.

That was a great win for pacquiao. Barerra was still prime. He might not have been undefeated super prime, but he certainly was still in his prime when pacquiao beat him. That beating he got from manny certainly nudged him just past prime.

sorry i can't agree, mab was past it after the second morales fight. The tapia fight does not count, tapia could'nt even fire his left due to a very bad injury, but still could'nt put him away. Mab was'nt ready for pac and felt it, the 3rd morales fight ended everything fo mab. Now i remember all this because i watched it live and remember all the analysis during. Still a good win for pac but no where near compairison to a floyd win vs mosley. But i don't even see floyd winning, i see a ko for mosley

[pelonxsoldier28]

why do you think that??? Pac fought the same cotto that beat shane..


Cotto could still beat mosley..

if you have to ask then you are already wrong. That was not even 75% of what cotto was after margacheato did what he did.