If floyd beats shane, is it a better win than manny's win against barrera?

[Sweet Jesus]

Shane is the better fighter, has the better skill, and is rated higher. The only thing you can compare is the age. But Manny did stop MAB in the 11th. If Floyd stops Mosley too, then the Mosley win is better. If not, then the MAB win holds court.

[Reloaded]

makes sense. counter-arguement anyone?

Mosley is better than Barrera , not by much but is a better fighter all around , I actually think Mosley at this stage is a better win than any in Pacs career.

[STRUGG]

Shane is the better fighter, has the better skill, and is rated higher. The only thing you can compare is the age. But Manny did stop MAB in the 11th. If Floyd stops Mosley too, then the Mosley win is better. If not, then the MAB win holds court.

hell no shane is old and inactive................................

[Titing Kabayo]

I don't know...It would be pretty close, only because of the situation they are in. Everyone thought Barrera was gonna bully Floyd. I'd put an old Shane ahead of a prime Barrera, but the situation was amazing for Pacquiao. That was a huge accomplishment for him, and it was the start of his reign. Before that he was fighting "tricycle men" or whatever he said about Valero. lol

Help me understand this part.....LOL

[miron_lang]

Shane is the better fighter, has the better skill, and is rated higher. The only thing you can compare is the age. But Manny did stop MAB in the 11th. If Floyd stops Mosley too, then the Mosley win is better. If not, then the MAB win holds court.

Mosley is better than Barrera , not by much but is a better fighter all around , I actually think Mosley at this stage is a better win than any in Pacs career.

LOL


Barrera

6 fights prior

Streak of impressive performances againts former champions in

Jesus Salud
Johny Tapia
Kevin Kelley
Erik Morales
Nazeem Hamed
Enrique Sanchez

Then went on another impressive run after the loss to Pacquiao
6 fights after

Paulie Ayala
Erik Morales
Fana
Robbie Peden
Rocky Juarez X2


Mosley


6 fights prior
Fernando Vargas X 2 - Well self explanatory to avoid the downplaying
Luis Collaso - Impressive
Miguel Cotto - LOST
Ricardo Mayorga - The KO saved shane but wasnt as impressive compared to the collazo fight
Antonio Margarito - Very Impressive



Its not even debatable at this point in time. Shane was a great fighter but not this version. This Version is not consistent. Shane needs another good run just to match what Barrera has done.

[Telepath]

Barrera wasn't in his prime when he fought Pac.

[Reloaded]

LOL


Barrera

6 fights prior

Streak of impressive performances againts former champions in

Jesus Salud
Johny Tapia
Kevin Kelley
Erik Morales
Nazeem Hamed
Enrique Sanchez

Then went on another impressive run after the loss to Pacquiao
6 fights after

Paulie Ayala
Erik Morales
Fana
Robbie Peden
Rocky Juarez X2


Mosley


6 fights prior
Fernando Vargas X 2 - Well self explanatory to avoid the downplaying
Luis Collaso - Impressive
Miguel Cotto - LOST
Ricardo Mayorga - The KO saved shane but wasnt as impressive compared to the collazo fight
Antonio Margarito - Very Impressive



Its not even debatable at this point in time. Shane was a great fighter but not this version. This Version is not consistent. Shane needs another good run just to match what Barrera has done.

Thing is at this weight 147 fighting Floyd you will see the best Mosley has brought to a boxing ring since he fought ODH , this is such afight to Shane he is hungry like he hasnt felt for many years ,,,, thats the difference .

[Ryannn]

its amazing this even reached 8 pages.

[Ryannn]

Thing is at this weight 147 fighting Floyd you will see the best Mosley has brought to a boxing ring since he fought ODH , this is such afight to Shane he is hungry like he hasnt felt for many years ,,,, thats the difference .

that's not a fact. that's an opinion.

fact is, barrera was on an impressive winning streak before him and manny fought. went on another impressive streak after their fight. he was very much prime, or at the very least, very close to it.

mosley struggled with mayorga, and his win over a one-dimensional, emotionally ****ed up margarito has been overrated recently.

regardless, a win against mosley is pretty solid, no denying it. not just as good as manny's win over barrera.

it ain't even close

[Ryannn]

Shane is the better fighter, has the better skill, and is rated higher. The only thing you can compare is the age. But Manny did stop MAB in the 11th. If Floyd stops Mosley too, then the Mosley win is better. If not, then the MAB win holds court.

by who?

you?