Hatton = "shot", Cotto = "shot", Margarito = "shot?"

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • -Antonio-
    -Antonio-
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jun 2005
    • 24259
    • 629
    • 164
    • 38,153

    #41
    I wouldn't be surprised if we saw the same old Margarito. All he did before was out last his opponent with an iron chin and a variety of slow punches. Hard to see him losing that.

    Comment

    • Hannibal Barca
      Hand of the Gods
      Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
      • Dec 2009
      • 2538
      • 152
      • 0
      • 8,893

      #42
      Originally posted by fightfan_79
      Just wanted to know everyone's take on this issue......

      According to a good number of "fans" on NSB....Hatton was never the same after getting KOd by the ringpost.....I mean Floyd.

      Cotto was never the same after getting BTFD (beat the f**k down) by bricks...I mean Margarito.

      So now does Margarito fall under that category of "shot" since the manner in which Mosley destroyed him was....BEAUTIFUL?

      Just wanted peoples' opinions......

      IMO...Margarito is done.
      Ask Freddy Roach, he'll tell you.

      Comment

      • check hook
        Gay Pride
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Jan 2010
        • 9361
        • 379
        • 137
        • 16,005

        #43
        Originally posted by fightfan_79
        Just wanted to know everyone's take on this issue......

        According to a good number of "fans" on NSB....Hatton was never the same after getting KOd by the ringpost.....I mean Floyd.

        Cotto was never the same after getting BTFD (beat the f**k down) by bricks...I mean Margarito.

        So now does Margarito fall under that category of "shot" since the manner in which Mosley destroyed him was....BEAUTIFUL?

        Just wanted peoples' opinions......

        IMO...Margarito is done.


        We won't know till he fights again....but smart money says he will never be the same. In the last few years he had a wars with Williams, Cotto (he took alot of clean punches from Cotto) and Shane really did a number on him. That kind of wear and tear takes a toll on any man. Couple that with inactivity and i think he is done as an "elite" WW.

        Martinez will push hard for a Margo rematch if he gets past Kelly. If i was Marg i would turn it down.....Martinez will whip him this time around.

        Comment

        • The Beatles
          Banned
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • Mar 2010
          • 1758
          • 146
          • 93
          • 3,117

          #44
          Originally posted by fightfan_79
          Just wanted to know everyone's take on this issue......

          According to a good number of "fans" on NSB....Hatton was never the same after getting KOd by the ringpost.....I mean Floyd.

          Cotto was never the same after getting BTFD (beat the f**k down) by bricks...I mean Margarito.

          So now does Margarito fall under that category of "shot" since the manner in which Mosley destroyed him was....BEAUTIFUL?

          Just wanted peoples' opinions......

          IMO...Margarito is done.
          add Morales to that list of shot fighters and the rematch with Barrera..

          list of shot fighters now includes, Hatton, Cotto, Morales, Barrera

          Margarito next???

          Comment

          • #1Assassin
            Conveyor of Truth
            Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
            • Jan 2008
            • 8019
            • 647
            • 264
            • 20,993

            #45
            Originally posted by fightfan_79
            Just wanted to know everyone's take on this issue......

            According to a good number of "fans" on NSB....Hatton was never the same after getting KOd by the ringpost.....I mean Floyd.

            Cotto was never the same after getting BTFD (beat the f**k down) by bricks...I mean Margarito.

            So now does Margarito fall under that category of "shot" since the manner in which Mosley destroyed him was....BEAUTIFUL?

            Just wanted peoples' opinions......

            IMO...Margarito is done.
            idk if floyd took all that much out of hatton, obviously anytime someone gets a beating like that it takes something out of them but hatton imo wasnt that good to begin with. cotto was clearly ruined and margarito, well we will just have to wait and see. i dont think margarito was all that good to begin with eighter, cotto fought a ******ed fight. had he not gotten big headed and forgot what brought him to the top he wouldve beaten margarito imo. the loss to mosley took something out of margarito (no way a beating like that couldnt) we will just have to see how much.

            Comment

            • Toe Injury
              Banned
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Dec 2009
              • 1048
              • 47
              • 18
              • 1,201

              #46
              people use "shot" interchangably with "has apexed"

              all of those guys have hit their apex in talent and didn't become #1, none of them are "shot" or have had their "chin cracked" etc -- finding your limits and being damaged goods arent the same

              but you know how boxing fans love to use cool "sweet science terms" in preference over correct statements

              Comment

              • ophqui
                Undisputed Champion
                Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                • Jan 2005
                • 1025
                • 35
                • 13
                • 7,607

                #47
                cant call margarito shot on the basis of one fight. His head probably wasnt in it since he'd just been caught cheating, so it wouldnt have been his best performance anyway, and who knows if his hands were loaded for cotto and previous fights? got to wait for his next few fights to have any idea, but it will take a lot for a top level fighter to be interested in him after the cheating, inactivity and the fact that he was soundly beaten in his last fight.

                I do think cotto is done as a top level fighter, hes tried 3 times (including mosely, where i think he was soundly beaten) to make the jump to elite level and failed each time. Hes still a great fighter, and hes a tough nights work for anyone, i just dont think he'll ever be 'great'. He'll never live up to his promise of being a threat to floyd, he'll never be an undisputed champion at any weight.

                As for Hatton. . .i think hes damaged beyond repair, and i think he knows it. I dont know whether it was the pac loss or the years of abuse hes given himself, but somethings not right, and his indecision over his retirement leads me to beleive that hes well aware theres a problem. I doubt he'll box again.

                Comment

                • brently1979
                  Undisputed Champion
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Jan 2007
                  • 1226
                  • 154
                  • 441
                  • 13,535

                  #48
                  Originally posted by o0P4PBOXING0o
                  Erik Morales is dominated by Zahir Raheem...BOOM Pacquiao fights him

                  Oscar Larrios is KO'd in 3 rds by Israel Vasquez...BOOM Pacquiao fights him

                  Oscar De La Hoya is beaten convincingly by Floyd Mayweather....BOOM Pacquiao fights him at a weight he hasnt fought at in several years

                  Ricky Hatton is knocked out by Floyd Mayweather....BOOM Pacquiao fights him

                  Miguel Cotto is beaten to a pulp by Margarito....BOOM Pacquiao fights him



                  See the pattern?
                  If you call a SD convincingly, they yeah he sure did.

                  Comment

                  • Pacquiao'd
                    Banned
                    • Mar 2010
                    • 11948
                    • 612
                    • 153
                    • 12,591

                    #49
                    Originally posted by Siggy
                    honestly, what do you think would happen if hatton got hit with the same shot manny landed on him if he never fought floyd?
                    manny didn't.have the.balls.to.do.so so your question ismoot

                    Comment

                    • Pacquiao'd
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2010
                      • 11948
                      • 612
                      • 153
                      • 12,591

                      #50
                      Originally posted by brently1979
                      If you call a SD convincingly, they yeah he sure did.
                      if you sawthefight, you knowthat floyd clearly won, the judges scored cards were bs.

                      dlh was hitting air all night

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP