(No hate thread) Do you consider mayweather one of the best Welterweights of this era

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Clottey > Baldomir.

You didnt answer the question.

[Drive Slow]

Clottey > Baldomir.

Clottey lost to Baldomir. I know it was a DQ (headbutting) but they say a win is a win, well then a loss is a loss.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

you gotta understand the context of the situation.

everyone wanted floyd to fight margarito or cotto, but floyd wouldn't for whatever reason.

so when floyd decides to fight judah, whom baldomir already beat, people had to ask floyd why fight judah instead of baldomir.

and at the time hatton was calling floyd out so people asked floyd about it.

but honestly, we all know baldomir was the weakest title holder and unified champ ever at WW. judah is a born loser and hatton is a fat slob.

when you compare these fights against the fights margo, cotto, and mosley took at WW, you should come to the realization that they are subpar.

bottomline: floyd's WW resume is very weak. that's not to say he's not a great talent or that he's not in the top 5 WW right now, but his resume at WW isn't elite. fighting mosley is a good first step to prove himself at WW.

that's like saying pac is an ATG jr WW... but pac only had one fight at jr WW, so how can anyone make a good case for it?

I dont think his WW resume is subpar.

Baldi and Judah were Top WW's. We can't go back in time to change history and discredit Floyd.

Hatton was also a top P4P fighter. People want to crap on it because he moved up yet those same people wouldve gave Cotto credit if he beat Pac who did the exact same thing. Move up.

Those are all good WW wins.

[Chunk..]

Clottey > Baldomir.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Clottey > Baldomir.

Thought so............

[Drive Slow]

Clottey > Baldomir.

Clottey beat Judah, the same guy who Floyd beat and Baldomir beat. Clottey lost to everyone else. Essentially Clottey=Baldomir.

[Chunk..]

You didnt answer the question.

Seen as you brought up Pacquiao for no reason whatsoever, why should i have too? I don't respond to question answers.

Clottey lost to Baldomir. I know it was a DQ (headbutting) but they say a win is a win, well then a loss is a loss.

Baldomir is better then Clottey. Cheers.

[KickAzz]

I dont think his WW resume is subpar.

Baldi and Judah were Top WW's. We can't go back in time to change history and discredit Floyd.

Hatton was also a top P4P fighter. People want to crap on it because he moved up yet those same people wouldve gave Cotto credit if he beat Pac who did the exact same thing. Move up.

Those are all good WW wins.

ok, i embellished a bit, but there were better fights at WW for floyd than judah and baldomir, they were "good" wins, but not great wins.

[Drive Slow]

Seen as you brought up Pacquiao for no reason whatsoever, why should i have too? I don't respond to question answers.



Baldomir is better then Clottey. Cheers.

Don't be mad.

[hugh grant]

Seriously i dont understand this thread. Floyd isnt even a top 100 WW.