If Hopkins Beat Jones Jr and then Beat David Haye, Would he a top 10 ATG?

[Southpaw16BF]

I kinda do....lol. Its in my head I know whos there and who isnt...lol.

lol. Convert it from your head to the keyboard, see what people think.

[Check]

I don't know how your top 50 looks like. But, he is in my top 50 already

I haven't really broke it down but of fighters of this era I would have BHOP and Roy in the 50-75, Pac in the top 20, and Floyd just outside of the top 25 with both being able to advance higher. BHOP beating an old Roy and a heavyweight that hasn't proven much would not move him that much higher up the list.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

lol. Convert it from your head to the keyboard, see what people think.

Ill start with my Top 25. Hows that?

[Southpaw16BF]

Ill start with my Top 25. Hows that?

Cool man.......

[Spray_resistant]

Mercado, John David Jackson, Echols, Holmes, Eastmen. Yeah all those guys ******. . Hopkins beat numerous excellent fighters in the 90s and early 2000s.

They weren't bums but Pavlik or Taylor for sure would have beaten any of those guys I think.

[Check]

He already is top 50, you're delusional. This is Bernard Hopkins we are taking about, not that quitting coward you like so much.

Cotto didn't spend his whole career picking on smaller guys. Not to mention the era of middleweights BHOP was in with weren't the most talented.

[street bully]

I haven't really broke it down but of fighters of this era I would have BHOP and Roy in the 50-75, Pac in the top 20, and Floyd just outside of the top 25 with both being able to advance higher. BHOP beating an old Roy and a heavyweight that hasn't proven much would not move him that much higher up the list.

What the **** has Floyd done to warrant a top 25 spot, who has a better resume Hopkins or Floyd? Jones and Hopkins 50-75, honestly wtf man?

[JAB5239]

You being serious? If he beats Jones Jr and Haye, he's easily a lock for top 25 surely........

No. Billy Conn beat many more great fighters than Hopkins and he's not a lock for the top 25.

[jrosales13]

What the **** has Floyd done to warrant a top 25 spot, who has a better resume Hopkins or Floyd? Jones and Hopkins 50-75, honestly wtf man?

I am not going to lie I have Roy outside my top 50. I think Hopkins has a better resume then Floyd. I hot Hopkins close to my top 40.

[street bully]

They weren't bums but Pavlik or Taylor for sure would have beaten any of those guys I think.

John David Jackson would have made Pavlik look like a bum, are you kidding me? Mercado would also outbox Pavlik. Echols would have KOed glass chin Taylor with his devastating punching power.