If Hopkins Beat Jones Jr and then Beat David Haye, Would he a top 10 ATG?

[The_Demon]

top 25 imo

[etlux]

Beating a corpse and a guy who hasnt done much at HW makes you a top 10 ATG?

If he beats Jones Jr, Chad Dawson, David Haye and One of the Klitschko's then he would be rated in the Top 40 maybe.

it's true the Jones win is moot and doesn't even count towards ANYONE'S legacy at this point. I could probably beat Jones at this point. Maybe I should join Joes vs. Pros.

[jrosales13]

No he would not and I don't think he would be close to the top 10 either.

[Spray_resistant]

Lets say if B-Hop were to defeat Jones Jr and then move up to HW and beat Haye for the WBA, and retired, would he be in your top 10 greatest fighters of all time?

Not even close, Roy is done, and though Haye would be a very good win he has what the Tarver win and a long run at MW which was weak at the time.

His resume as of now is slightly greater than Calzaghe's even though he lost to him and these legacies are based off of long runs as champs in weak divisions but B-hop moving up and beating Tarver puts him ahead of Joe.

[jrosales13]

Not even close. He could end up in the top 50...maybe.

I don't know how your top 50 looks like. But, he is in my top 50 already

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Hopkins is already Top 50.

A win over Roy does nothing but getting a Heavyweight Title pushes him to Top 25 on my list.

[jrosales13]

Beating a corpse and a guy who hasnt done much at HW makes you a top 10 ATG?

If he beats Jones Jr, Chad Dawson, David Haye and One of the Klitschko's then he would be rated in the Top 40 maybe.

If B-Hop did all that. IMO he would be easily top 20 arguably in the top 10.

[Southpaw16BF]

Hopkins is already Top 50.

A win over Roy does nothing but getting a Heavyweight Title pushes him to Top 25 on my list.

Have you got a ATG list in order? If so, i'd like to see it.

[street bully]

Not even close, Roy is done, and though Haye would be a very good win he has what the Tarver win and a long run at MW which was weak at the time.

His resume as of now is slightly greater than Calzaghe's even though he lost to him and these legacies are based off of long runs as champs in weak divisions but B-hop moving up and beating Tarver puts him ahead of Joe.

Mercado, John David Jackson, Echols, Holmes, Eastmen. Yeah all those guys ******. . Hopkins beat numerous excellent fighters in the 90s and early 2000s.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Have you got a ATG list in order? If so, i'd like to see it.

I kinda do....lol. Its in my head I know whos there and who isnt...lol.