If Hopkins Beat Jones Jr and then Beat David Haye, Would he a top 10 ATG?

[Parody]

If B-Hop did all that. IMO he would be easily top 20 arguably in the top 10.

To be top 10 ATG you have to beat ATGs...There are too many great fighters in that list...He is in my top 50-55 but beating a dead corpse in Jones Jr now doesnt do anything for him at this point, infact it does nothing for him.

David Haye win would be good if Haye established himself at Heavyweight, im a Haye fan but I know he hasn't done that yet, and hopefully it starts from a knockout victory or dominant win over Ruiz, Haye just won the HW title in his last fight in a close decision over Valuev.

Hopkins needs to beat Chad Dawson and a Klitschko to be in the my top 30-40 as his best wins have been over guys smaller than him (Oscar, Tito, Wright, Pavlik) I give him credit for facing some guys that are his size or bigger in Prime Jones Jr, Calzaghe, Taylor and Tarver he lost most of these. Bottom line is, I want to see Hopkins face someone in his prime who is his size or bigger, and dominate the way he does.

If your going to fight at Heavyweight or Lightweight why not pick the best fighters in that weight class? (Klitschko and Dawson)

Bare in mind Dawson and Klitschko arent even ATG's, but Hopkins will deserve to move up in the list for beating good fighters in their primes who are similar size or bigger.

[jrosales13]

No. Billy Conn beat many more great fighters than Hopkins and he's not a lock for the top 25.

Grat point, I have outside of my top 30.

[street bully]

Cotto didn't spend his whole career picking on smaller guys. Not to mention the era of middleweights BHOP was in with weren't the most talented.

Cotto loses to 1 dimensional bums like Margarito. His only notable win is over Shane Mosley. At this point Cotto isn't even close to a hall of famer.

[Check]

What the **** has Floyd done to warrant a top 25 spot, who has a better resume Hopkins or Floyd? Jones and Hopkins 50-75, honestly wtf man?

Corrales for starters is a better win than anyone Hop beat. Floyd has a solid resume. There ain't nothing wrong with being in the top 100 fighters of all time. Boxing has been going strong for nearly 150 years.

[Southpaw16BF]

No. Billy Conn beat many more great fighters than Hopkins and he's not a lock for the top 25.

Hmmmmm. Really. Hopkins would of won more title at more weights, and I think thats going to far saying he had much better wins. Like to compare?

This is including if he beats Haye and Jones also.

Hopkins's resume of wins.
John David Jackson
Glen Johnson
Simon Brown
Felix Trinidad (40-0)
Oscar De La Hoya
Antonio Tarver
Ronald Wright
Kelly Pavlik
David Haye
Roy Jones Jr

Thats a damn impressive resume of wins. And Conn's is no way much better.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

1. Ali
2. SRR
3. Louis
4. Armstrong
5. Pep
6. Johnson
7. Dempsey
8. B. Leonard
9. Langford
10. R. Leonard
11. Duran
12. Hearns
13. Greb
14. Wilde
15. Gans
16. Charles
17. Canzoneri
18. Foreman
19. Moore
20. Walker
21. Frazier
22. Chavez
23. Tunney
24. Ketchel
25. LaMotta



Off the dome. So If Im missing a big name please dont jump down my throat on it.

Might as well make a thread on it. I'll go up to 50. And just keep adding to this list.

[Check]

Cotto loses to 1 dimensional bums like Margarito. His only notable win is over Shane Mosley. At this point Cotto isn't even close to a hall of famer.

That's fine and I agree. You're the one draging Miguel into it, I never said he was greater than HOP.

[jrosales13]

He is in my top 60 but beating a dead corpse in Jones Jr now doesnt do anything for him at this point. David Haye win would be good if Haye established himself at Heavyweight, im a Haye fan but I know he hasn't done that yet, and hopefully it starts from a knockout victory or dominant win over Ruiz, Haye just won the HW title in his last fight in a close decision over Valuev. Hopkins needs to beat Chad Dawson and a Klitschko to be in the my top 30-40 as his best wins have been over guys smaller than him (Oscar, Tito, Wright, Pavlik) I give him credit for facing some guys that are his size or bigger in Prime Jones Jr, Calzaghe, Taylor and Tarver he lost most of these. Bottom line is, I want to see Hopkins face someone in his prime who is his size or bigger, and dominate the way he does.

If your going to fight at Heavyweight or Lightweight why not pick the best fighters in that weight class? (Klitschko and Dawson)

His accomplishment is nothing to sneeze at either. 20 title defenses, unified undisputed mw champ, skipped a weight-class to LHW to beat the champ. Plus his resume as a MW is not that much behind Marvin Hagler resume. Where do you rank Hagler?

[street bully]

Corrales for starters is a better win than anyone Hop beat. Floyd has a solid resume. There ain't nothing wrong with being in the top 100 fighters of all time. Boxing has been going strong for nearly 150 years.

Corrales? Homie, you have to be kidding. RIP but Coralles is overrated as hell. Trinidad, Wright, Tarver, and even Pavlik are all better than he was. Correles is not an ATG and should not even be a first ballot hall of famer.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

1. Ali
2. SRR
3. Louis
4. Armstrong
5. Pep
6. Johnson
7. Dempsey
8. B. Leonard
9. Langford
10. R. Leonard
11. Duran
12. Hearns
13. Greb
14. Wilde
15. Gans
16. Charles
17. Canzoneri
18. Foreman
19. Moore
20. Walker
21. Frazier
22. Chavez
23. Tunney
24. Ketchel
25. LaMotta



Off the dome. So If Im missing a big name please dont jump down my throat on it.

Might as well make a thread on it. I'll go up to 50. And just keep adding to this list.

Sweet Pea?