If Hopkins Beat Jones Jr and then Beat David Haye, Would he a top 10 ATG?

[Southpaw16BF]

Lets say if B-Hop were to defeat Jones Jr and then move up to HW and beat Haye for the WBA, and retired, would he be in your top 10 greatest fighters of all time?

[djtmal]

no........

[Check]

Not even close. He could end up in the top 50...maybe.

[BigStereotype]

Absolutely not.

[Southpaw16BF]

Not even close. He could end up in the top 50...maybe.

You being serious? If he beats Jones Jr and Haye, he's easily a lock for top 25 surely........

[etlux]

it depends in what fashion he beats them. In controversial crappy decision then definitely not.

If he puts on a clinic and even KO's Haye for example (and Haye goes on to have an outstanding career) then maybe he'll be top 15-20 not sure about 10 I'd have to think about that

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Ive never bothered to make one of these mythical "ATG" lists that everyone goes on about. But looking at the two wins on their own merit - beating Roy right now doesnt mean a whole lot. Beating Haye would be an impressive achievement considering Hopkins age and size. Although Haye has not really proven himself fully at HW yet. It'd be more impressive than Roy n Toney beating Ruiz I think.

[Boxing Scene]

You being serious? If he beats Jones Jr and Haye, he's easily a lock for top 25 surely........

David Haye isn't great. You have to beat great fighters to be great. Valuev? Come on dude. That's a joke.

[Parody]

Beating a corpse and a guy who hasnt done much at HW makes you a top 10 ATG?

If he beats Jones Jr, Chad Dawson, David Haye and One of the Klitschko's then he would be rated in the Top 40 maybe.

[street bully]

Not even close. He could end up in the top 50...maybe.

He already is top 50, you're delusional. This is Bernard Hopkins we are taking about, not that quitting coward you like so much.