i want to try something.

[boxer2k5]

Well cong**** TS in making a thread that seems to have progressed in an unbiased and flame free manner.

it doesnt bother me. least it got guys who at least try to post facts right or wrong. and not dumbass posters posting rumors and myths

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

i said oscar was past his prime but at least floyd fought him with all oscar demands. manny fought way past prime oscar plus weight drained.

and to say castillo won 1 and lost one thats not facts thats opinion.
if you say that then you can make a case that manny lost to JMM twice.
but on paper on record he didnt.

and thats bull**** about corrales i watched that fight so many times they never mentioned that bull****. and if he couldnt make weight why was diego still campaigning at super feather for the next 3 years? why wasnt he at lightweight if he couldnt make the super feather limit?

i know gatti was shot or w.e thats why i said nothing much to say here because everyone knows that

LMAO, TS have is own agenda. Good luck, a will let the *******s come in, **** your thread up!

[Rocky!]

Pac res/legacy>Floyd's
deal with it
if he beats Shane Floyd gets closer, still must beat Pac
if he beats Pac after that, he can surpass Pac

[Haterfree]

OK, Ill play your game then !!


Corrales - He was weight drain even during the fight the announcers where saying Corrales requested the fight to be at 135, because he could no longer make 130 healthy

Castillo - Beat Floyd once, lost once.

Gatti - Was shot to ****

Hatton - he fought him at 147, where Hatton wasnt at his best weight.

DLH - Old past prime

JMM - old and small LW and he fought him at 142. in wich he didnt even made the weight.


So FLoyds best wins are judah and Baldomir

Anybody who knows **** about boxing stopped reading at Castillo. Get your facts straight & stop telling lies hater. Also Floyd beat the late great Diego Corrales at 130 Diegos previous 5 fights had been at 130 or lower but somehow according to an idiot hater like you he was weight drained. STFU

[Spray_resistant]

it doesnt bother me. least it got guys who at least try to post facts right or wrong. and not dumbass posters posting rumors and myths

It can be done for a few pages at most what you are trying to do but whenever you make threads about an issue or fighters ppl really care about as if they were relatives by the time you check on the thread a few hours later it turns into mostly childish name calling.

[tesla_power]

really? who Cotto?

Yes. Who else was there? Cotto is debatable but only with SSM or Marg. Others like Floyd should not be mentioned in the WW FOTD because his body of work there was not that significant at this weight.

[immortal tech]

Quintana
Judah
Mosley
Margarito
Clottey
Pacquiao


What name is missing on that list?

Dude I don't care about Floyd I need you to explain to me how is Cotto the best WW of the decade

[Haterfree]

Pac res/legacy>Floyd's
deal with it
if he beats Shane Floyd gets closer, still must beat Pac
if he beats Pac after that, he can surpass Pac

All Floyd has to do is pass his 1st random drug test for the Mosley fight & his legacy will be better than Pacs.

[The Beatles]

im confused with the question at hand...nevertheless, fans from both sides are trying to dicredit Floyd and Pac

[boxer2k5]

Pac res/legacy>Floyd's
deal with it
if he beats Shane Floyd gets closer, still must beat Pac
if he beats Pac after that, he can surpass Pac

thats what you saying but explain why? is your point because manny fought bigger names? but those guys have established names dont mean they were the same fighters.