Mosley has a better resume then Floyd because he lost to Winky and Vernon?

[Walt Liquor]

You just made my point homie. There records arent comparable Burton fought a 135 Pound Mayweather. Who on Calzaghes resume compares to that? Using yall logic? Shane has fought the better competition. No one denied that. But when you say his resume is better then Floyd because he lost 4 fights to Winky and Forrest that makes no sense.

idiot, i said record

a) record
b) competition
c) longevity at the world class level.

see post 43

[krispy kreme]

Shane will not win a title in a 5th weight class.

Shane did not start out at Super feather weight and he skipped Junior Welterweight.

I would like to know what the point of your post is, because you once again sound like a cheerleader.

[Walt Liquor]

I would think your resume is your wins and losses as it represents your entire professional career. Saying that losses is not part of the resume, seems like you're disregarding the effort a fighter put into the preparation and the pain they've endured in that fight...

and the knowledge they gained in a losing fight to use for the future, it's called experience and it's the basis of your resume. it doesn't matter if you succeed at everything, it's what you learn along the way. i know burner will never have a business, hire a good employee, or be successful at all in life based on this conversation right here. poor guy is obese...

[bojangles1987]

You just made my point homie. There records arent comparable Burton fought a 135 Pound Mayweather. Who on Calzaghes resume compares to that? Using yall logic? Shane has fought the better competition. No one denied that. But when you say his resume is better then Floyd because he lost 4 fights to Winky and Forrest that makes no sense.

That's one name though. No one name defines a person's resume. Calzaghe's level of competition is very comparable to Emmanuel Augustus.

Shane's resume isn't better than Floyd's BECAUSE he lost to Winky and Forrest, they are just part of the level of competition that is consistently higher than what Floyd has faced, which is why Shane has a better resume.

[krispy kreme]

and the knowledge they gained in a losing fight to use for the future, it's called experience and it's the basis of your resume. it doesn't matter if you succeed at everything, it's what you learn along the way. i know burner will never have a business, hire a good employee, or be successful at all in life based on this conversation right here. poor guy is obese...

I agree, but I don't know how these boxing historians or experts would define a boxer's resume. I would be interested to hear it from someone who has been around for a while and has always watched the sport.

When I hear the word resume, experience does comes to mind. Regardless if you fail or succeed, the point is that you have been there.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

Shane did not start out at Super feather weight and he skipped Junior Welterweight.

I would like to know what the point of your post is, because you once again sound like a cheerleader.

So you have to start at SF to move up?..lol.


Shane has been at 135, 147 and 154. Call me when he wins a title at 160 and 168.

You said Floyd doesnt go through Shanes fights undefeated and I said he wont win a title in a 5th weight class.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

That's one name though. No one name defines a person's resume. Calzaghe's level of competition is very comparable to Emmanuel Augustus.

Shane's resume isn't better than Floyd's BECAUSE he lost to Winky and Forrest, they are just part of the level of competition that is consistently higher than what Floyd has faced, which is why Shane has a better resume.

Since when is getting your ass beat a good thing. I mean you have to actually WIN in this sport.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

and the knowledge they gained in a losing fight to use for the future, it's called experience and it's the basis of your resume. it doesn't matter if you succeed at everything, it's what you learn along the way. i know burner will never have a business, hire a good employee, or be successful at all in life based on this conversation right here. poor guy is obese...

Talk boxing or get put on ignore. Last warning. The flame wars on NSB are so played out.

[bojangles1987]

Since when is getting your ass beat a good thing. I mean you have to actually WIN in this sport.

That's where rankings and discussion of how good a fighter comes in. The resume is not part of that, that's where a record comes into play.

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

That's where rankings and discussion of how good a fighter comes in. The resume is not part of that, that's where a record comes into play.

Obviously this thread is going no where....lol. Good talk in here though.

My whole thing is when someone says resume they mean wins.Matter of fact I'll prove it.