Williams is ranked a Top 5 P4Pounder on many lists.

[IMDAZED]

And im crazy? lol

He was ranked in the top 20 and he was the favorite for that bout. This is fact, not opinion.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

How was he outboxed by Martinez? Martinez said that was the toughest fight of his career.

It was a tough fight, doesnt mean he didnt get outboxed in the majority of the rounds.

[El Castigador]

Young as opposed to the likes of Floyd, Shane and BHop.

I have Ward and Dawson above him.

Thats great but most boxing writers have Williams over Dawson and they dont even have Ward on the lists to begin with.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

He was ranked in the top 20 and he was the favorite for that bout. This is fact, not opinion.

Winky Wright was favourite against Paul Williams? Hopefully I just mis-read....hopefully.

[El Castigador]

It was a tough fight, doesnt mean he didnt get outboxed in the majority of the rounds.

If he was outboxed every round how was it a fight of the year candidate? Was Floyd vs. Gatti a F.OT.Y Candidate?

[S.G.]

Thankfully, it's NOT based on that. Because a lot of fighters look good when matched with nobodies. It's why resume is the chief criteria, then skills.

Like I said in the post you quoted, you can't judge skills accurately without the résumé to back them up so both are ultimately as important as each other.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Thats great but most boxing writers have Williams over Dawson and they dont even have Ward on the lists to begin with.

And I argue with my own opinion instead of constantly using the media to try to back me up....lol wtf?

[Pretty Boy Greg]

he aint no P4P yet, but LIke chicana said, if Donaire is there, hell Ill put Willaims at #3 efore letimg Donaie get into my p4p list!

the dude is practically owning three weight classes right now... how in the hell is that not p4p!??????

[IMDAZED]

Winky Wright was favourite against Paul Williams? Hopefully I just mis-read....hopefully.

Why hopefully? He either was or wasn't.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

If he was outboxed every round how was it a fight of the year candidate? Was Floyd vs. Gatti a F.OT.Y Candidate?

I said the majority of the rounds. Floyd did not outbox Gatti, he ******ed him. Out of curiosity, where do you rank Sergio?