Why does Floyd always say "aks" instead of "ask"?
Collapse
-
-
im a black man from the west coast and while english wasnt my first language, people in my area of california dont use that vernacular, i have known lots of non blacks to say it like that as well.Comment
-
Did a little Googlin' my own self and found this at englishforum dot com:
"Furthermore, from what I have read, it is not at all clear whether "ascian" came first or whether "acsian" did. Has new scholarship actually identified which was first?"
Checking the etymology in AHD, they say both forms are from the reconstructed Germanic *aisko^n, which in turn is from Proto-Indo-European ais-sk-, from a root ais- 'to wish, desire'. I take it from this that in West Germanic the -ks- version developed from the -sk- version, as indeed one would expect, yes? (It seems less conceivable that a -ks- could become a -sk-.)Comment
-
Prolly is a contraction, not a phonetic reversal of consonants.
As I said earlier:
If Floyd can read/write (check) , AND avoid saying "Mayweafer" (check)...
...but hey, I don't really care. As long as we can understand what's
said. I was simply agitated by the false etymology posted in support
of "aks", and the number of good people misled by it.Last edited by horge; 02-09-2010, 05:03 PM.Comment
-
Perhaps you're right. But from my knowledge of the word it originally came from aksian or axian. I'm far from an expert on the subject, so if I am mistaken, then it was (as you say) an honest mistake.Comment
-
Comment
-


Comment