Yes or No: Mosley and Margarito should be banned from Boxing?

[JAB5239]

"Attempting to cheat" is cheating. He "attempted" to defraud his opponent and the fans, and could have seriously hurt someone. Disgrace to the sport, Penalty should be the same.

So you're saying what Luis Resto did and What Margarito did are the same? Lmao!!! Whats next we start scoring punches that don't land because the fighter attempted to land it? Please.

[one-Punch]

big difference margarito loaded his gloves shane should have got his win vs dlh changed to no contest and maybe suspended margarito should be banned for life

I agree with this guy, but not for life.

[pistol whip]

People trying to compare Mosley and Margarito are ******, different offenses care different penalties. The boxing word resoundingly believes that Loaded gloves are the worse offense in boxing (Worse then PEDs), there for its treated that way and many feel it should result in life time bans.

The thing is his gloves wernt loaded (at least not how you think). They were w****d illegally and no it doesn't make it better but from my understanding they wrapped in a way to protect Tony's hands.

[JAB5239]

I agree with this guy, but not for life.

Exactly. Now if there was proof Margs used loaded gloves, not attempted but actually used them in a fight I'd say ban him for life. There is no such proof though.

[The Gambler1981]

So you're saying what Luis Resto did and What Margarito did are the same? Lmao!!! Whats next we start scoring punches that don't land because the fighter attempted to land it? Please.

If I attempt to murder someone do I not go to jail? If I attempt to commit fraud do I not go to jail? If I attempt to steal do I not go to jail?

He attempted to commit a boxing crime he should be punished accordingly. He does not need to go to prison like Resto though~

[Roxas]

tho Margarito is far worse (loading ur gloves cud potentially kill a person)
they both shud be banned i'm sick of cheaters in the sport....

[JAB5239]

If I attempt to murder someone do I not go to jail? If I attempt to commit fraud do I not go to jail? If I attempt to steal do I not go to jail?

Was Margarito not punished? Did his reputation and financial situation not suffer enormously because of this?

[The Gambler1981]

Was Margarito not punished? Did his reputation and financial situation not suffer enormously because of this?

He has been but it should be more severe, maybe if he showed some remorse I could feel sympathy for him but as it sits now he deserves to rot as far as I am concerned.

[pistol whip]

If I attempt to murder someone do I not go to jail? If I attempt to commit fraud do I not go to jail? If I attempt to steal do I not go to jail?

He attempted to commit a boxing crime he should be punished accordingly. He does not need to go to prison like Resto though~

Comparing cheating in a sporting event to felony crimes is like comparing apples to elephants.

[The Gambler1981]

Comparing cheating in a sporting event to felony crimes is like comparing apples to elephants.

Look at the comparison he made comparing attempting to cheat to attempting to land punches, my comparison is atleast comparing like situations.

Laws are rule and if you attempt to break the rules you get penalty, same with breaking rules in sports you attempt to cheat you get the penalty. It is an apples to apples comparison just one is more severe then the other.