Is Cotto already a Hall of Famer?

[shade darkar]

You're missing my point. What did Saad Muhammed and Rosario do that makes them HOFers but not Cotto?

We have to judge them all the same way.

so if you put cotto in based on the fact that other people made it in, then that means you'd put hatton in? that cant be right.

[dans]

so if you put cotto in based on the fact that other people made it in, then that means you'd put hatton in? that cant be right.

I would put Hatton in. Why shouldn't Hatton be in there? He won the JWW title and held it for years.

I'm saying, the judging criteria must be fair and consistant. If you stick with that, both Cotto AND Hatton should be in the HOF.

[shade darkar]

I would put Hatton in. Why shouldn't Hatton be in there? He won the JWW title and held it for years.

I'm saying, the judging criteria must be fair and consistant. If you stick with that, both Cotto AND Hatton should be in the HOF.

fair enough, personally i dont think either should be in, but you never know i suppose, they could well end up in.

[Dondi33O]

How? Cotto was beaten to a bloody pulp against a guy who probably had plaster in his wraps.

Duran wasn't even hurt. He was just frustrated.

Who's the bigger quitter?

It depends on whether you think a psychological beating is worse than a physical beating or vice versa.

[- v e t -]

if buddy mcgirt isnt in yet, miguel cotto shouldnt be

[Ravishing]

Cotto will be in the HOF. Not immediately, but he'll be there in the future.

[ericsantos]

HOF yes ATG no

[boxerca]

Hard to say, at the moment. He does have Mosley, Judah, Clottey and Malignaggi. It's all debatable. If he gets a couple more high quality wins like those, he'll get in.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Yes, Cotto has fae 13 champs or former champs, he shoudl had been the unified champ, but the IBF ****ed him over and he won 3 titles in 2 divsion.

He have one of the better resumes in the past 5 to 6 years!!!1

[dans]

It depends on whether you think a psychological beating is worse than a physical beating or vice versa.

I would say since quitting is a psychological decision, that quitting by way of psychological beating is worse. Duran was still very much "in the fight" against Leonard, he just didn't want to chase Leonard around and quit. Cotto was still fighting even though he was backing up. He just knew his body was done for the night.