Who has defeated more fighters in their PRIME: Mayweather or Pacquiao?

[jekbu]

Barrera had two losses to Junior Jones(one by TKO) and two wars with one loss to Morales when he fought Pacquiao so he was not in his "absolute" prime. I can agree he was close but no way was he in his absolute physical prime.

hmnnn.. so the not so prime manny is beating the **** out of all his opponents recently?

geez.. im thinking what a prime manny can do..

[Doctor_Tenma]

Styles make fights... Corrales would have taken off Barrera's head. Corrales is no slouch... he connected against anyone he fought (exception being Floyd)... nothing against Barrera but this would have been bad for him...

JMM = Castillo... Castillo in his prime was never beaten he only lost on cuts... the only reason he has a bad rep is because of the weight thing. Marquez probably a slight better then Castillo.

Hatton = Hatton

Cotto can't even be compared to Genaro... they never fought in the same weight class... but if you want to at the time Genaro was considered the best at the weight and Cotto probably the best at WW

Diaz = Baldomir

Ledwabba, Sasakul = I don't know them enough to dare to compare them to someone

Corrales would have taken Mab/ EM's head, this I agree with. Ganero would stand a really good chance at beating those 2 also.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I think the thread is about accomplishments.

It's not a head to head matchup mate.



Side notes:

Barrera is 126-135 fighter
Corrales is 130-147 fighter

They are not the same size

Castillo was stopped by Cesar Sotto a career Featherweight. I can say Pac never lost in his prime.

Barrera is more 126-130.
Corrales is more 130-140

[Cash Cow]

LOL yea he did... I think it was for the 2nd fight. He threw a punch and then Morales tried to retaliate but Barrera used his foot work to get the hell out of the way.

[Calilloyd]

The prime Barrera, JMM, Morales and Cotto who Pac fought even if they are past in their prime will still beat any fighter in Floyd resume if they are in the same weight classes. That's why most boxer experts (they are not same races with pac) chosen Pac in higher atg/legacy status than Floyd. I believe them because their words have more weight than Floyd fans who are bs on their own fighter.

The Morales who Pacquiao fought is not beating the Corrales or Jose Luis Castillo that Mayweather fought. Barrera wouldn't have beaten beaten Corrales either. I would favor the JMM pac fought over any of them and Cotto over any welterweight Mayweather has fought.

[miron_lang]

Barrera is more 126-130.
Corrales is more 130-140

that could be their optimum weight but MAB fought at 135 officially and Corralles fought at 147 officially.

Corrales is bigger obviously. but MAB wins it if they are the same size.

[The Stone Roses]

morales, barrera, de la hoya were all past their prime...diaz is a nobody....cotto was plastered by margarito and had a war with clottey before pac decided to fight him and hatton was coming off a damaging loss to mayweather......mayweather's opponents have been fresher and in their prime....diego, zab, de la hoya at 154, undefeated hatton

[miron_lang]

Corrales would have taken Mab/ EM's head, this I agree with. Gane

ro would stand a really good chance at beating those 2 also.

No ****ing way LOL

Erik Morales UD's Genaro all month everyday same with Barrera. Genaro is not at that level.

[AFTER HOURS]

morales, barrera, de la hoya were all past their prime...diaz is a nobody....cotto was plastered by margarito and had a war with clottey before pac decided to fight him and hatton was coming off a damaging loss to mayweather......mayweather's opponents have been fresher and in their prime....diego, zab, de la hoya at 154, undefeated hatton

was pacman undefeated when he fought all those past prime?

[jekbu]

again.. being prime is subjective.

so can we say Pac, having already lost 3 times, (downed twice -i may be wrong) is beyond PRIME?

Pac is beating the hell out of his recent opponents and yet he is not PRIME.

His opponents, having lost some fight is not prime?

Can please someone please shed light?